>FMA is good because... it just is okay?

Original was a masterpiece but with a shitty ending.

Brotherhood was a shitty buddy cop series with a good ending.

LOL, thats funny

>It's ok when One Piece does it

>>280061827
>Shitterhood
>Good ending

>>280061486 (OP)
>shonen that actually ends
>simply builds up towards a confrontation with big bad and follows through
>no major character assassinations
>no bullshit powerups
>every villain is set up early and all receive good ends
>only one villain is brought back from the dead
>barely any heroes get resurrected
>good world building
>no clear author's favorite characters
Its good

>>280062214
No it fucking isn't

>>280062272
>no argument
Yeah you faggot

IT'S THE SAME FUCKING THREAD EVERY FUCKING DAY

>>280062214
yes, it's a very focused manga, there's almost nothing superfluous in it
if it was written today we would already have some unnecessary sequel and the manga would have double the amount of volumes
with an obligatory shitty card and/or gacha game
the author had a very clear idea of what the story should be about it stays true to that message and it's solid all around
I'm not really fond of the characters, but that's a me thing, they all have motivations that are relatable and fit in with the rest of the story
I think FMA is the poster boy for consistency
that insufferable retarded shitposter who kept posting the same image over the years is right about one thing, the comedy is really shitty

>>280062714
Multiple times a day, even.

>>280061486 (OP)
The formula of joke, serious, joke, serious really doesn't work when it's so condensed but some times it's funny.
>>280062214
I wish mangaka could sit down and write out their god damn plots like this. It takes like a month tops with an editor to corral any retardation.

>>280062314
>rushes the first part of the story
>skips the mining town, train fight, most of the Ishvalan backstory, etc
>adds shitty filler like hulk cornello and the ice alchemist
>bad characters like the panda girl that do nothing in the story
>riza stops roy from killing envy because revenge will make you as bad as envy or some bullshit like that, and the rest of the gang join her, because roy is in the wrong for wanting to avenge the death of his friend
>envy also dies like a little bitch
>muh power of friendship wins over greed and causes pride to reincarnate because asspull
>which means it also causes father to lose despite having absorbed the power of god
>al gets his body back through ass pull (pic rel) that could've happened at any point in the story and makes the journey pointless
>no real sacrifice at the end, just happily ever after slop
You need to go back to MAL or some shit you flaming retard

Take your meds funnyschizo.