Anime > Manga - /a/ (#280208653) [Archived: 691 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:31:57 PM No.280208653
Pon_no_Michi_Manga
Pon_no_Michi_Manga
md5: 25479df76e9c7c95f26c7f9ec4546f1e🔍
There's a lot of cases where the manga is better than the anime, but what about the opposite? How many times is the anime better than the manga? Look at KyoAni saving the garbage that was the K-ON! manga. Same thing happened with Pon no Michi, they took one of the worst manga ever made and made it almost watchable.

What are the best examples of anime improving upon the source material?
Replies: >>280209083 >>280210517 >>280211731
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:33:50 PM No.280208701
The Pon no Michi manga was based on the anime
Replies: >>280210125
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:36:08 PM No.280208753
Well in this case it's because the anime and the manga were made at the same time. Usually to sell to people without DVD players, or for busy salarymen to read on the train
It's actually quite common to have a manga made alongside an original anime. DIY has one, Shuumatsu Train has one, even Gurren Lagann has one too
Replies: >>280208827
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:38:46 PM No.280208827
>>280208753
Except DIY and TTGL had good manga.
Replies: >>280208865
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:40:12 PM No.280208865
>>280208827
does TTGL have a better ending?
Replies: >>280208887 >>280211817
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:41:04 PM No.280208887
>>280208865
Are you asking if the manga has a better ending than the anime or are you incapable of speaking English?
Replies: >>280208935
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:42:45 PM No.280208935
>>280208887
>ignoring the context of the conversation
yes, I'm asking if the manga of TTGL has a better ending than the anime since you implied you've read it, you dolt
Replies: >>280208989
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:44:37 PM No.280208989
>>280208935
No, the ending is similar, a little worse in execution.
Replies: >>280209012
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:45:41 PM No.280209012
>>280208989
well that's disappointing
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:48:25 PM No.280209083
>>280208653 (OP)
Almost all the 4-koma are and SHOULD be better to the manga otherwise the studio Is incompetent
Replies: >>280209109
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 7:49:17 PM No.280209109
>>280209083
The appeal of 4koma is its simplicity, anime automatically detracts from that.
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 8:28:34 PM No.280210125
>>280208701
Have you read either of the manga? They aren't remotely based on the anime.
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 8:44:30 PM No.280210517
1749150284651_thumb.jpg
1749150284651_thumb.jpg
md5: 589868a9b6698ae919e3aa41be1276b7🔍
>>280208653 (OP)
Hare + Guu definitely
One of the very few cases I know
I read the manga after watching it just to see the difference and even besides having a really bad TL, it was just noticably more amateurish (understandable as it was the mangaka's first serialization)
The anime basically took 90% of the meat of the manga, rearranged a lot of stuff, added some content here and there, adjusted some scenes (up to changing which characters a scene happened to) and in the end made a much better story out of it, much more coherent.
Masterwork of adaption I'd say.
Also adding in Guu's movements and voice was a huge bonus.
Replies: >>280210574
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 8:47:16 PM No.280210574
>>280210517
also amazing music
especially OPs and EDs
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3_06C6fjgfA
my favorite
Replies: >>280210681
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 8:52:07 PM No.280210681
>>280210574
The music alone made it go from a 7/10 to a 10/10
Replies: >>280211286
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 9:17:24 PM No.280211286
1749535540103
1749535540103
md5: ef0d68c081b4a4bb51c7d81374cd8645🔍
>>280210681
and hare's mom brings it up to 11
weda-chan...
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 9:26:23 PM No.280211522
KyoAni is an exception to the rule, everything and anything they make is better than the original.
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 9:30:59 PM No.280211636
check em
check em
md5: 7d444670fb3163391f0e578769846eb8🔍
Is this the thread?
Replies: >>280213007
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 9:35:12 PM No.280211731
crim
crim
md5: 83d173df9b7ae27f328cba54786fdf89🔍
>>280208653 (OP)
Recently read the Interspecies Reviewers manga and the anime is better. The manga is actually more censored than the anime.
Hope it gets a 2nd season, but I doubt it. There's enough manga content for it though.
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 9:39:03 PM No.280211817
>>280208865
Super Robot Wars has a good ending
Anonymous
7/3/2025, 10:27:51 PM No.280213007
>>280211636
Not if you got the wrong digits.