Coil – A Circle of Children - /a/ (#281108647) [Archived: 514 hours ago]

Anonymous
8/1/2025, 6:54:05 PM No.281108647
Dennō_Coil_vol_1_DVD
Dennō_Coil_vol_1_DVD
md5: 741ac814457404cb89f48d159dc27672🔍
i hear (from animators) that this is the very peak of japanese animation as a craft. what do you guys say?
Replies: >>281110377 >>281111633 >>281112809 >>281114591 >>281114827 >>281120457
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 7:20:56 PM No.281109501
sokah.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 7:28:00 PM No.281109732
It was a very straight-forward story. Had a message to tell, which funnily enough, was the scrapped ending of Neon Genesis Evangelion
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 7:47:37 PM No.281110377
>>281108647 (OP)
I like it a lot. The “very near future” sci-fi is something that should be explored more by the industry in general, I guess robo waifus are in this category now so it is a bit weird. It also gives a Ghibli feel but with sci-fi, a genre Ghibli avoids. Also cool that they didn’t made adults incompetent retards to make the kids look cooler. The parents and even the grandma are competent in the use of the AR technology even if the show focus on the kids. If my life went as I expected when I was 20 I would have watched it with my kids today but instead I’m posting on 4chan alone.
Replies: >>281110430 >>281112017
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 7:49:23 PM No.281110430
>>281110377
>If my life went as I expected when I was 20 I would have watched it with my kids today but instead I’m posting on 4chan alone.
Bro why the fuck did you have to hit me with that holy shit I felt it
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 7:53:17 PM No.281110548
Imagine if someone at Ghibli decided to make a TV anime after watching Lain. That should give you an idea.
Replies: >>281111164
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 8:11:15 PM No.281111144
Extremely ugly and boring.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 8:11:59 PM No.281111164
>>281110548
that sounds kinda great desu
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 8:22:40 PM No.281111526
Story was OK but the main draw is the CGI quality
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 8:26:01 PM No.281111633
>>281108647 (OP)
Animation was great. The children aren't sexy for once so mostly lolicons will hate on it and say it's "Extremely ugly and boring."
Replies: >>281112541 >>281116747
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 8:39:55 PM No.281112017
>>281110377
If my life went as I expected when I was 10 I would have watched it with my kids today but instead I'm posting on 4chan alone since I was 20.

ftfm
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 9:00:08 PM No.281112541
>>281111633
>The children aren't sexy for once so mostly lolicons will hate on it and say it's "Extremely ugly and boring."
Incredible fucking revisionism, Dennou Coil saw an explosion of hentai more than most other "lolicon" shows of that era.
Replies: >>281114414
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 9:10:39 PM No.281112809
>>281108647 (OP)
Chill show produced at the perfect time for it to get a decent number of episodes so it could properly tell its story. Unlike the more recent Iso Mitsuo work which could've been so much more if it wasn't rushed.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 10:12:40 PM No.281114414
0bb23d8453cd190a1c1b754eef8b8062
0bb23d8453cd190a1c1b754eef8b8062
md5: 73635a95e663486120a69c4ae98a71ae🔍
>>281112541
If you think this is sexy that's your opinion
Replies: >>281117834
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 10:14:23 PM No.281114456
e311f4dbe74a8d3bc6851572b8b861db
e311f4dbe74a8d3bc6851572b8b861db
md5: 18260554615b05fbcc3e2233c08e4470🔍
Non-sexy children.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 10:19:58 PM No.281114591
>>281108647 (OP)
I wouldn't call it peak, but it's very good.

Also watch Kamichu.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 10:28:46 PM No.281114827
>>281108647 (OP)
I was shocked to see this on Netflix.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 11:09:12 PM No.281116095
Is Dennou Coil peak craft? I dunno. I think personally the show's animation is pretty limited (it helps if you don't permanently burn bridges with your animation director and fire him mid run), the scene composition is above average for its time which makes it way better than today, and most of the show's real strength is in how good the 2d/3d mixed element composition is. Japan's integration of 3d into their 2d shows is either 'we don't care that it looks out of place' or if you're lucky 'we're deliberately using that out of place look to create uncanny feelings'. Count on two hands how many anime in the last 20 years are really interested in visually integrating 3d/2d into a holistic feeling composition. Dennou Coil is one of them.
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 11:29:59 PM No.281116747
1721175651268173
1721175651268173
md5: a2affbd5f3f2e58a260c5fff47deca5b🔍
>>281111633
The real sexiness comes from the inside
Anonymous
8/1/2025, 11:42:37 PM No.281117103
I don't really know about that, but Mitsuo Iso is definitely one of the best animators when it comes to capturing movement, and this is basically his Masterpiece.
He also did an episode of Rah Xephon and of course is famous for the Asuka sequence in EoE.

In terms of animators I would still rate Norio Matsumoto higher as he was incredible both at naturalistic movement and action, not that Iso can't do both but he mostly settled into the naturalistic side for much of his career as a key animator.
Replies: >>281119645
Anonymous
8/2/2025, 12:06:02 AM No.281117834
1211668647971
1211668647971
md5: cfe00f072af3e2308741c1d3bad9bc41🔍
>>281114414
You ask that here, of all places.
Anonymous
8/2/2025, 1:22:45 AM No.281119645
>>281117103
I think Matsumoto's action work is disqualified from naturalistic by the 00's.
You can put him in pure webgen stuff like Birdy Decode and none of his cuts in that look like they don't belong there.
Anonymous
8/2/2025, 1:58:50 AM No.281120457
>>281108647 (OP)
It sure is.
/a/ doesn't know shit about sakuga anymore though, all the reasonable and well-informed people left for other communities.
Expect more discussion about the story or fixations on the artstyle rather than craft.