Thread 281206768

Why is it so overrated? Can someone please help me understand? I've seen this bullshit 13 times now and I still don't understand how it could possibly be seen as anything other than generic shonen kiddie slop

>>281206768 (OP)
Take your meds funnyschizo.

>>281206768 (OP)
This guy just makes like 30 threads flooding /a/ with his bad takes.

I only care about best boy.

>281206955
Fuck off Selimfag, not even giving you a (you). Imagine being this sad that you feel like you need to derail threads whenever someone criticizes your precious little Brotherhood

I didn't derail shit, retard. I literally said I only care about him, and you said you watched the show 13 times.

>>281206991
There's no thread here to derail funnyschizo, just your deranged ramblings. Take. Your. Meds.

>>281207034
Well your taste is shit and Selim is ugly, kys fma fag

Not so gr8 b8, m8

>>281206768 (OP)
it was written in 2001. when you contextualize it, it's pretty remarkable. the reason it feels "overrated" now is probably because you're unconsciously comparing it to more advanced, contemporary stories.

>>281207284
The manga was mediocre back then too, the anime original adaptation made it look better than it was but then Brotherhood revealed that no, the source material really was bad. I think 2003 is closer to its contemporaries like Monster (see pic rel), more deep

>>281208291
Take. Your. Meds.

>>281206768 (OP)
Is this the only way to have these threads now?

>>281206768 (OP)
>I've seen this bullshit 13 times
Watch it at least one more time and you will understand.

>Cringe.png
>4fu2gf0flsz21.jpg
>1728330319996.webm
>reddit.png
>funny.png
>fma is shit.jpg
>Fullreddit Alchemist.png
>Beats god with the power of friendship.gif
>Doesn't stay true to the main theme.png
>Dumb writing.png
>didyoulaugh.gif
>revenge bad... because it is okay!.jpg
>Fullredditor(1).png
>Fullredditor (2).jpg
>Fullflop Alchecrap.png
>Death.webm

>>281208674
I am convinced it's got to he a copycat troll because I don't know how someone can reuse all these filenames and go "ITS NOT JUST ONE GUY HATING YOUR REDDITSLOP"

>>281206768 (OP)
You never heard? 14th time's the charm!

>>281208790
Autism. Pure, unfiltered autism.

>>281208291
comparing FMA to Berserk and Monster is a bit "apples to oranges" don't you think? FMA is ultimately an optimistic adventure with an uplifting ending, even if it has some dark twists and turns.

>>281206768 (OP)
Fullmetal Alchemist both original series and Brotherhood received a shit ton of praise and when praise probably should have been calmer.
I liked Brotherhood overall but I get annoyed by the "killing is wrong no matter what" bullcrap type of protagonist.

>>281206768 (OP)
>>281206955
>>281206991
>>281207034
Daily reminder that funnyschizo accidentally posted a shota image and quickly deleted it before posting his usual drivel but it was too late. Now he desperately tries to deflect by posting about Selim (likely using pics from his own folder kek) to accuse bhfags of being the shotafags despite 03 being the source of all the fujo/incest pedo shit in this fandom. He has actually become funny kek.

>>281206955
But enough about Envy.

>>281206768 (OP)
> I've seen this bullshit 13 times now

>>281209934
I don't understand what's so amusing. You faggots on MAL, anilist, etc keep insisting that IT'S SO FUCKING AMAZING AND PEAK!!! but every time I watch it I just notice all the flaws and what a pile of shit it is. I mean it's a fucking "faithful" adaptation but it adds a lot of filler

>>281210021
At least it's not #1 on MAL anymore but the fact that it was #1 at all is so fucking embarrassing how do these retards even live with themselves, Brotherhood is one of the most cookie cutter shonen slop of all time and it infuriates me that there are people who think it was "peak" or whatever zoomer shit they regurgitate

bump

>>281208790
You're looking at it rationally. Schizos are not rational.

bump

>>281208790
schizos tend to be huge narcissists too, so they can't help themselves from having a signature style. they want you to know they exist.

>>281206875
who
youre seeing smokes where there is none

>>281208291
THIS

>>281206768 (OP)
It's literally only "highly rated" by troons on mal.