Would Star Vs have been better if Marco was always or at some point been turned permanently into a girl? Would FemMarco have improved the series?

No. Just like eating a whole can of frosting. You enjoy this fetish content only because its actual presence in the show was very light and played for laughs.
An actual fetish show, or even one full step in that direction, would actually be very boring and inane. Keeping it lowkey, to the point of vanishing, invites you and everyone else to imagine their own special version of the thing. You start laying into the sacred stones exactly how things are and you make 1 group happy and all the others mad.

Tom being a girl would have been neat though honestly a better protagonist than Star in later seasons.

>>148989153 (OP)
Nah

>>148989153 (OP)
The point is to have a fucking boy wear the dress, you idiot!

>>148989527
Erm, that's not Tom, that's meant to be Tom's SISTER.

>>148989153 (OP)
Stop making half assed thread and call or Rule63 thread instead

>>148989615
Marco being forced to crossdress is pretty hot, I also think Marco getting turned into a girl agienst his will is also hot.

>>148989766
>>148989615
This is my point in action. Both versions of the fetish can exist in the vague wishy washy canon. If the show were all about how marco literally is, or literally is not, a girl then that axes 1 crowd.

Scott would be interesting as a girl.

>>148989615
Fair

>>148989708
Seethe.

>>148989153 (OP)
>Would Star Vs have been better if Marco was always
No
>or at some point been turned permanently into a girl?
Yes
>Would FemMarco have improved the series?
Yes

>>148989527
I think it would have been better if Tom was a girl and Stars exgirlfriend.
She would also flirt with Marco because that kind of actual love triangle is funny.

>>148989615
Is it weird that the first time I saw Marco in the princess disguise, my first thought was
>Wow... that dress could hide a really big diaper

>>148991106
Disney would never do a story like that then and won't do it now either for opposite reasons.

>>148989153 (OP)
>turned permanently into a girl?
Fuck no. Stay a boy, keep the dress.

>>148991340
Based