Does hrt override everything enough to say you are? I see a lot of debate on twitter so tell me

>>40274906 (OP)
yeah

>>40274906 (OP)
no thats why i'm a TRANS man. this debate is retarded

>>40274906 (OP)
I don't think "biological man/woman" is a very useful or precise term

>>40274911
Explain I want to understand

>>40274924
because i am biologically a man

>>40274933
But you have to take hormones no?

>>40274906 (OP)
i don't think those terms are very meaningful. im a woman. im a woman who is a transsexual, but im not really meaningfully male anymore either

>>40274949
nta, but that's a very dubious criterion, as that would exclude cis men/women with hypogonadism and post menopausal cis women

>>40274949
yeah

>>40274949
i have a cis male friend who had to take hgh in order to not be a total cispooner so.
he took that in high school and it wasn't controversial at all btw

>>40274906 (OP)
people who label themselves or each other as "biologically" male or female are just "biologically" stupid

the whole biological man or biological woman thing is kinda a dumb binary. many pretransition trans women have been observed to have more phenotypically female brain structures and when people take hrt it does change their sex characteristics, so using that either or, really fails to capture certain biological realities. it also misses social realities in how it get way over emphasized in discourse that is rly fundamentally about trans ppls roles in society rather than their biology. so while hrt doesn't "override" everything, that actually isn't important. the whole question is a dumb psyop trap bc it tries to frame biological realities as absurdities with this patently false dichotomy. so if ur not a retard, dont fall for this bait

>>40275044
>many pretransition trans women have been observed to have more phenotypically female brain structures
every tranny who says this fails to back their claim up by showing a brain scan

>>40274906 (OP)
im biologically feminized, but that doesn't make me biologically female

>>40274906 (OP)
I don't really care bro I don't think about these things I take my pills and live my life

>>40274906 (OP)
i am biologically female
>b-but you have a peni-
I AM BIOLOGICALLY FEMALE

>>40274906 (OP)
twitter trannies have been calling themselves biologically female lately is there anything to actually back this up besides E making them feminine

>>40275060
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih gov/articles/PMC8955456/
pre-hrt brain structures in transwomen, notably differentiated from cismale, resting between cismale and cisfemale groups

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih gov/40145530/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih gov/30082887/
brain structures of tgirls change on hrt, furthering similarity with cis women

here are some studys that document brain differences. its obv not 1:1 but shows brain structures to be distinctly different from biological men, before hrt and more so after.

sorry ftms most of these studys are about trans women for some reason (prolly bc the world still sees u as women and so wont properly dedicate funding towards research for u)

>>40275060
I show my brainscan if you show your brainscan first

>>40275084
some penis can be surprisingly feminine

>>40275170
isn't that enough though, E is very femine already

>>40275380
i still don't see how a penis can be feminine. like smaller yes but it's still essentially male

>>40275343
>>40275380

show brainscan or shut up

>>40274906 (OP)
yes I’m a biological man who takes estrogen and pretends to be female bc it makes him happy

>>40274958
>>40275061
>>40275170
All men who enter women's bathrooms are bad men. Even the ones in frilly dresses with girly feelings. You are bad men

>>40275416
do you think that every tranny has a brain scan?

>>40275457
no, i don't think any of them do, because they're frauds pretending to have female brains

>muh brainscans
honcope

>>40274906 (OP)
yes. my vehemence abt this is why I was allowed to transition as a minor in the 2010s

>>40275438
i was never a man. i'm a woman who enters women's bathrooms in jeans feeling like i need to piss. ive never even worn a dress

>>40275416
you first
or maybe you have something to hide ?

>>40275402
it's just a matter of habit and who is wielding it

>>40275507
i'm not making any claim that requires me to show a brain scan

>>40275530
autism/schizophrenia/other mental illnesses are identifiable with brainscans but nobody gets diagnosed with them

>>40275552
they do use brain scans in schizophrenia to exclude structural lesions that can have the same effect
however, autism is also fake as fuck
autism in particular has distorted its diagnostic criteria so much that the rate has gone up 50 times and fueled insane anti-vaxx conspiracy theories

>>40275465
>>40275507
bro doesn't know that medical diagnostics is primarily done through inference :0