Critique - /lit/ (#24477776) [Archived: 930 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:56:49 AM No.24477776
chara broly
chara broly
md5: c0d3da975bd8e06d557bdf79438d5ce4🔍
Roast it or like it.
https://pastebin.com/QzK1Q2Y0
Replies: >>24477888 >>24477899 >>24479192
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:58:16 AM No.24477888
>>24477776 (OP)
Your excerpt is a vivid, chaotic, and imaginative blend of mythic fantasy, absurd comedy, and philosophical art-world satire — and it's genuinely fun to read. Here's a breakdown of what works exceptionally well and a few suggestions for refinement to improve pacing, clarity, and emotional cohesion.


---

What’s Working Very Well

1. Voice and Style

Fresi’s narration is consistently witty, dramatic, and whimsically unhinged. Her internal monologue — switching between existential musings, comedic panic, and genuine artistic inspiration — is a huge strength.

The juxtaposition of ancient mythological aesthetics (togas, goddesses, divine muses) with absurdly modern quirks (“can I floss my teeth with spider hair?”) creates a unique tonal identity, reminiscent of Discworld, Mob Psycho, or Adventure Time with classical ambitions.


2. Characters with Clear Personalities

Fresi is a chaotic mess of passion, ego, curiosity, and anxiety — and that makes her compelling.

Brons is like a Dumbledore crossed with a conspiracy-obsessed dad, walking the line between wise and ridiculous.

Milos is mysterious, seductive, and aloof, giving a needed tonal shift amidst Fresi’s mania.


3. Worldbuilding

There's strong world texture here: the spiders, pine forests, enchanted sketchbooks, puppeteer ants, and a society built around artisan worship. The terminology (“Demigrus,” “The Sublime,” “sage arts”) suggests deep lore while still remaining readable.
---

Suggestions for Refinement

1. Trim Some Excess to Improve Pacing

The piece is dense. While the prose is lively, too many metaphors and whimsical tangents in a row can exhaust the reader.


Example:

> “The citrus ooze…my goodness it's sublime. The ooze is balanced in both citrus sweetness and bitterness and the slime texture makes the taste linger…”
This is fun, but consider trimming the indulgent tasting note down to a punchier line. Let moments breathe before jumping into the next absurdity.

2. Clarify Stakes Earlier

The spider chase is vivid, but we aren’t fully grounded in why Fresi's world is like this, or what makes this day so different. You hint that she’s diverging from routine — that’s a good seed, but you could plant it more clearly:


Example fix:

> “But today will be different. I’m sick of grapes, of art blocks, of playing it safe. So I chose a new path.”
That small clarity sharpens the reader’s understanding of the upcoming chaos.

Would you like to keep polishing this or move forward with the next part?
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:01:31 AM No.24477899
>>24477776 (OP)
Go back to your containment thread
Replies: >>24477989
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:48:56 AM No.24477989
>>24477899
did you read?
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:44:08 PM No.24479192
>>24477776 (OP)
it sucks