Thread 24480508 - /lit/ [Archived: 989 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/20/2025, 1:34:33 AM No.24480508
51baVClrzaL._SL1198_
51baVClrzaL._SL1198_
md5: 7f10940df08a8fd755713634f401f208๐Ÿ”
Just bought this and it arrives tomorrow, what am I in for? I've only read the usual recommended plato stuff
Replies: >>24480741 >>24481029 >>24481092 >>24481158 >>24481768
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 4:22:48 AM No.24480741
>>24480508 (OP)
Reading 30 or 40 pages of it before putting it on your self and watching it gather dust.
Replies: >>24481029
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 7:14:24 AM No.24481029
Socratic-Logic-Edition-3-1-Kreeft-Peter-9781587318085
>>24480508 (OP)
>>24480741
Or trade it in for picrel and get a modernized introduction to Aristotelian logic, syllogisms, categories, and fallacies.
Replies: >>24481168 >>24483401
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 8:01:28 AM No.24481089
The translation is shit and the material in general is gonna filter you, should have just bought better translations of works that interest you with better companion essays and such. No point in buying this unless itโ€™s a requirement for a philosophy class where the professor wants that translation. Itโ€™s cheap, so just see how you like it. Nichomachean ethics is a good start.
Replies: >>24481185 >>24481603 >>24481768
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 8:05:37 AM No.24481092
>>24480508 (OP)

that's a nice cover, it makes me want to consoom
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 8:54:59 AM No.24481158
>>24480508 (OP)
I, too, ordered this translation. I hope itโ€™s not total shit.
Replies: >>24481768
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 9:05:34 AM No.24481168
>>24481029
>modernized
I will never understand why this is recommended on /lit/ of all places. You are an embarrassment to your past, /lit/.
Replies: >>24481191
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 9:13:31 AM No.24481185
>>24481089
Fuck, Iโ€™m going to return it.
Replies: >>24481193
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 9:20:42 AM No.24481191
>>24481168
Larp on.
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 9:22:25 AM No.24481193
>>24481185
it's not total shite; give it a quick read before you return it though
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 2:36:32 PM No.24481603
>>24481089
>The translation is shit
Who are the translators for this version?
Replies: >>24481688 >>24481768
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 3:28:35 PM No.24481688
>>24481603
McKeon
Replies: >>24481768
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 4:07:47 PM No.24481755
What is the best translation?
Replies: >>24481768
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 4:13:31 PM No.24481768
1710699251408825
1710699251408825
md5: 9a9451d73bebe33373fa63fb2096fe5b๐Ÿ”
>>24480508 (OP)
>>24481089
>>24481158
>>24481603
>>24481688
>>24481755
>reading Aristotle translated
You fags, you must learn ancient greek but not only that, you must learn Heidegger and then go back to the greek text to read it not as it has been translated but in the way the true meaning arises, you must break colossal hermeneutical barriers, and to do that you learn, after years, that learning Nietzsche will get you closer to the meaning Aristotle was giving out than any other author out there, and to get that you've got to go even deeper in Heidegger.
So, learn ancient greek, then read Heidegger, then go back to Aristotle, then go back to Heidegger, then go to Nietzsche and then back to Heidegger to then, at the end of your life, go into Aristotle once again.
Replies: >>24482605 >>24483407
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 9:38:03 PM No.24482605
>>24481768
aquinas didn't know greek and he was the authority on Aristotle
Replies: >>24482611
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 9:38:49 PM No.24482611
we can't
we can't
md5: ce159ea9e893d07d6bceca45ad9d5b3b๐Ÿ”
>>24482605
Heidegger is the authority, cuck boy
Anonymous
6/21/2025, 2:08:22 AM No.24483401
>>24481029
actual throw-up. actual vomit and a disgrace to the original text and philosophy in general. do not ever read this. if you want to read ancient philosophy, read ancient philosophy and stick with it. importantly, you'll notice that there is logic in those books, but there is much more to make it applicable to a healthy life. logic on its own is a void
Anonymous
6/21/2025, 2:11:32 AM No.24483407
>>24481768
great bait. while it's not necessary to understand aristotle, heidegger can be fun to read!