ASOIAF - /lit/ (#24528382) [Archived: 427 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:28:54 AM No.24528382
imafges
imafges
md5: c8b2fe333b3021446d09f8928f2e056d🔍
My problem with this book it's that it's all nobles, lords and ladies making the calls. Why can't there be common folk involved and be important to the story? Really kills my immersion. Makes me think GRRM is just a cuck to the royal family.
Replies: >>24528387 >>24528456 >>24529047 >>24530379 >>24532125 >>24534107 >>24535939 >>24536601 >>24537301 >>24538394 >>24538396
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:31:33 AM No.24528387
>>24528382 (OP)
>GRRM is just a cuck to the royal family
miss the part where 99% of them are incestuous rapists and the ones who aren't continuously get their shit kicked in?
Replies: >>24528392
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:34:24 AM No.24528392
>>24528387
GRRM is a top gooner to these royals
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:40:44 AM No.24528400
Royalty are better than you
Replies: >>24528417
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:53:04 AM No.24528417
>>24528400
no, they ain't
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:09:39 AM No.24528433
Best you'll get is Davos. I can't see High Sparrow riding high forever. You can hope Littlefinger comes out on top but it's doubtful. He was also a minor noble to begin with. After that it's really just the Brotherhood without Banners. I think most of the Night's Watch characters are nobles too. Very grim, GRRM.
Replies: >>24532372
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:15:31 AM No.24528443
what about hot pie? huh? yeah, thought so
Replies: >>24528448
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:17:58 AM No.24528448
>>24528443
I bet that's GRRM's self-insert.
>commoner
>lowkey
>fat and ugly
>"important" but not enough to overshadow the cute lords and ladies
Replies: >>24532149
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:23:52 AM No.24528456
>>24528382 (OP)
All of the Nights Watch are commoners
Replies: >>24528459
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:25:57 AM No.24528459
>>24528456
Yeah, and the lord commanders are all noblemen, the head at black castle is some Targaryen, Sam is a nobleman. The commoners are just grunts who take a beating. Even the wildling king was some fucking lord.
Replies: >>24528462 >>24530867
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:27:15 AM No.24528462
>>24528459
Is the literal gay twink lowborn?
Replies: >>24528464
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:27:53 AM No.24528464
>>24528462
Who?
Replies: >>24528467
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:29:17 AM No.24528467
>>24528464
Satin. He worked at a brothel in Oldtown so he must have been a commoner.
Replies: >>24528472
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 7:30:58 AM No.24528472
>>24528467
That nigga gay
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:25:53 PM No.24529047
>>24528382 (OP)
It kills your immersion that nobles controlled a feudal society, particularly one where they had access to dragons and magic that commoners had no chance of using?
Replies: >>24532564
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:34:05 PM No.24529065
This series tried to be more grounded in realism than fantasy before it, which is why it is so influential. The people with the most power would be making all the calls in a world like this.
Replies: >>24529119
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 3:58:21 PM No.24529119
>>24529065
>and then the tree wizard became king. The end
George suuuuuuuucks
Replies: >>24529157 >>24529358
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 4:22:20 PM No.24529157
>>24529119
I mean whatever. All fantasy sucks.
Anonymous
7/7/2025, 6:19:23 PM No.24529358
>>24529119
Blud, even the previous tree wizard was a Targaryan. How many of these fuckeroonis are there. Is everyone a fucking lord in Westeros? Fucking hell.
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 2:03:33 AM No.24530379
>>24528382 (OP)
because peasants fucking suck
fuck em
fuck em in the ass
Replies: >>24530786
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 5:08:32 AM No.24530786
>>24530379
These aren't your typical peasants. They're masons, architects, soldiers of really impressive cities. They're not our ordinary folk. And you're telling me they haven't organized themselves to just fucking kill every single shitty ruler? At least irl, those rulers did not last thousands of years like in the books.
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 5:59:36 AM No.24530867
>>24528459
Peasants rarely do anything of note, anon.
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 8:43:39 PM No.24532125
>>24528382 (OP)
Read the Gesta Danorum, the type of original text that influenced the fantasy genre. It’s constantly praising the nobility and denouncing the commoners, and throughout the book, one of the most heroic acts one can commit is the prevention of marriage between the two. That’s the original material which authors have to work with. The old stories were written by bards who were funded by kings, to write about kings, and so it’s about the kings that we know the most about.
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 8:51:58 PM No.24532149
>>24528448
That would be Samwell Tarly.
Anonymous
7/8/2025, 10:46:52 PM No.24532372
davos
davos
md5: b1c245889f4b62c5bd1608fb62162662🔍
>>24528433
Davos is a bootlicker, but for Stannis so it's ok.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 12:29:36 AM No.24532564
>>24529047
Commoners should be way more powerful within cities. Places like King's Landing just feel like the lords, and the unwashed masses, with barely anything in between.
Anonymous
7/9/2025, 4:17:49 PM No.24534107
>>24528382 (OP)
They have no power, lol
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 3:02:45 AM No.24535939
>>24528382 (OP)
read lotr
Replies: >>24537321
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 3:19:19 AM No.24536003
How might characters like Griffith and Le'garde or figures like Napoleon handle the chaos in Westeros?
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 8:57:33 AM No.24536601
>>24528382 (OP)
>Why can't there be common folk involved and be important to the story?
the pyromancers are common folk
the antler men
Clegane's men
the brotherhood without banners. Tom of severn cums specifically.
Janos Slynt
>Makes me think GRRM is just a cuck to the royal family.
nobles aren't all the royal family.
Replies: >>24537919 >>24538190
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 4:35:16 PM No.24537301
>>24528382 (OP)
Retarded 4channer in a nutshell.
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 4:49:29 PM No.24537321
>>24535939
The best advice you can give to any GRRMfag.
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 9:29:18 PM No.24537919
>>24536601
Plus socially lesser folk like Sam Tarly, Brienne, Davos, Barristan, Aereo Hotah, Arys Oakheart, and Melisandre, and those are all POV characters. Plenty of other side characters as well.
Replies: >>24538190
Anonymous
7/10/2025, 10:56:15 PM No.24538190
>>24536601
Pyromancers are gay and irrelevant
Antler men are gay and irrelevant
Clegane's men is lead by Clegane, which is a house of the royal family.
Brotherhood without banners is led by noblemen with recognizable names.
Slynt is a noblehouse from the royal family.

Nobles are still nobles.

>>24537919
Those niggas are rich nobles nigguh. Tarly is among the most recognizable houses.
Anonymous
7/11/2025, 12:12:29 AM No.24538394
>>24528382 (OP)
Because gurrm is a retard who has a very shallow understanding of how feudal society worked during the late middle ages
Anonymous
7/11/2025, 12:13:12 AM No.24538396
>>24528382 (OP)
bourgeois ideology, that's why