Was Dostoyevsky a fascist? - /lit/ (#24546586) [Archived: 325 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:32:04 PM No.24546586
rtrtr
rtrtr
md5: 728c16815e40a1a45b418cc9b1af4b74🔍
Ukrainians are saying you shouldn't read him because of that.
Replies: >>24546636 >>24546707 >>24547126 >>24547143 >>24547204 >>24547229 >>24547248 >>24547480 >>24547572 >>24547596 >>24547642 >>24547643 >>24547868 >>24547951 >>24548324 >>24548352 >>24549335
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:40:17 PM No.24546611
1696208555121-1
1696208555121-1
md5: a86d49a9b770b9758f93e48324eceffa🔍
Everyone russian is a heckin fascist
Replies: >>24546619
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:43:01 PM No.24546619
>>24546611
Double dubs and /thread
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:47:17 PM No.24546634
Worse than fascist, he is indeed basic ass shit. Every 17 year old boy who wants to look deep in front of his crush reads Dostoevsky
Replies: >>24547147 >>24547264 >>24547310
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 6:48:17 PM No.24546636
>>24546586 (OP)
>>24546292
this thread seems a bit redundant no?
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 7:07:58 PM No.24546707
>>24546586 (OP)
I know I am falling for the bait, but how is Dosto fascist?
Replies: >>24547132
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:20:28 PM No.24547126
>>24546586 (OP)
Fascist? Rich coming from khokhols. Also le wypipo don' season they meat— c'mon, how cucked to pindostani spiritual nigdom are they? Yet these queens of spades don't want to touch the Prince of Poets Pushkin? Um, czech your privilege!
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:23:21 PM No.24547132
2 chudded 2 care
2 chudded 2 care
md5: 7b6286cdfbda9cbab8c113a496d4ec03🔍
>>24546707
He didn't like Jews and clearly National Socialists (who are identical to Fascists) invented anti-Semitism
Replies: >>24547138
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:24:34 PM No.24547138
>>24547132
>and clearly National Socialists (who are identical to Fascists) invented anti-Semitism
Then how do you explain the hundreds of times Jews were expelled before the 1930s?
Replies: >>24547202
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:25:57 PM No.24547143
>>24546586 (OP)
I’m from Ukraine and I like dosto. Most people do
Some ultranationalist types don’t like
Bulgakov anymore ig but most don’t care. He lived in different times.

please do not listen to retards on Twitter. He is probably NAFO posting from Kansas
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:27:06 PM No.24547147
>>24546634
no one reads dostoevsky to impress women
the archtype of person you are describing literally doesn't exist
Replies: >>24547415
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:40:14 PM No.24547201
Ukrainians have earned their place on the pride flag.
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:40:41 PM No.24547202
>>24547138
Do you have autism or possibly a low IQ?
Replies: >>24548329
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:41:11 PM No.24547204
>>24546586 (OP)
Dosto is a fascist, but these retards will argue until they're blue in the face that Bandera wasn't one
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:48:31 PM No.24547229
>>24546586 (OP)
>random twitter post with 25 (!) views
>LOOK LOOK /POL/ ALL UKRAINIANS THINK THIS
books?
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:51:03 PM No.24547248
>>24546586 (OP)
I HATE HOHOLS LIKE YOU WON'T BELIEVE.
like they aren't even an original country.
Replies: >>24547311
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:55:03 PM No.24547264
>>24546634
The very act of describing the plot of Crime and Punishment Sri any girl at 17 is guaranteed to scare them away from you.
Replies: >>24547415
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 9:59:07 PM No.24547282
Literal who on twitter has an opinion thread. 200 replies incoming
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:05:35 PM No.24547310
>>24546634
He was also a pedo
Replies: >>24547313 >>24547332 >>24547752
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:06:21 PM No.24547311
>>24547248
Day 1,235 of the 3 day special mission
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:07:50 PM No.24547313
>>24547310
He was based then?
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:11:33 PM No.24547332
>>24547310
how
Replies: >>24547377
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:24:25 PM No.24547377
>>24547332
How not? His books are full of pedo men. Read Matzneff.
Replies: >>24547422
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:32:52 PM No.24547415
>>24547264
>>24547147
Never said the crush was a woman.
Never said the Dostoevsky reader was successful in his attempts. But that’s who reads him. He’s the epitome of I’m a teenager and this is deep. Look at all the posts on this board saying Underground Man or Raskolnikov are ‘literally me’. He’s not a writer for grown ups - he’s Ayn Rand for teens who just discovered nihilism
Replies: >>24547457 >>24547641 >>24547770
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:34:01 PM No.24547422
>>24547377
>writing about a certain kind of people makes you one of them
are you retarded? I hope this is bait for your own good
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:45:07 PM No.24547457
>>24547415
why would a nihilist read dostoyevsky
Replies: >>24547770
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 10:57:28 PM No.24547480
>>24546586 (OP)
Zainichi Ukrainians, they are so BAD, how could they think this thing

Thank you OP for bringing this Twitter issue to our attention.
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 11:34:15 PM No.24547572
>>24546586 (OP)
Don't care. I'm still reading russians writers, they are pretty good. Not my problem cuckranians, you voted a kike, you get what you deserve.
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 11:39:24 PM No.24547580
Ukrainians are mad jealous because no one, save for paid shills cares for ukrainian culture. Hence the never-ending butthurt when some celebrity mentions russian authors as their favorite. has nothing to do with "fascism". pure jealousy and attention seeking

t.ukie
Replies: >>24548005
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 11:48:08 PM No.24547596
>>24546586 (OP)
calm down azov
Anonymous
7/13/2025, 11:55:37 PM No.24547609
I really don't get all the hate for Ukraine, they are literally defending their homeland and you want them to just surrender lmao. Like how their government is handling it isn't perfect but they aren't the aggressors
Replies: >>24547628 >>24548005 >>24548054
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 12:03:26 AM No.24547628
>>24547609
Your thoughts on Israel-Palestine?
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 12:07:08 AM No.24547641
>>24547415
Dostoevsky is completely against nihilism. What are you talking about?
Replies: >>24547770
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 12:07:12 AM No.24547642
>>24546586 (OP)
all those pictured in your Shitter screenshot are american
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 12:08:05 AM No.24547643
>>24546586 (OP)
No, retard
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 12:42:56 AM No.24547752
>>24547310
Ordering his entire bibliography rn
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 12:49:50 AM No.24547770
>>24547415
>>24547457
>>24547641
Dostoevsky himself was the exact opposite of a nihilist, but that hasn't stopped edgy teens from acting like he was a nihilist. Kind of the same way most people accuse Nietzsche of nihilism. Neither of them was a nihilist, it's their shitty fanbases co-opting their work for the edgy "aesthetic" because they don't bother to actually read their work and just want the image of someone who reads Dostoevsky or Nietzsche.
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 1:30:11 AM No.24547868
>>24546586 (OP)
Fascism didn't exist in the 1800s, so not really, though he was somewhat of a reactionary. Contemporary Russia is bad btw.
Replies: >>24547870
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 1:31:16 AM No.24547870
>>24547868
what contemporary nation is good?
Replies: >>24547889
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 1:36:20 AM No.24547889
>>24547870
The Anglosphere, anything in the EU, Japan, South Korea. China has potential but Communism is holding it back from being more than just a place with a decent GDP growth rate.
Replies: >>24548015
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 2:11:34 AM No.24547951
>>24546586 (OP)
Ukrainians need to be banned from the internet until we can figure out what's going on
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 2:39:37 AM No.24548005
>>24547580
Hey, Gogol at least is incredible, even in translation. And that’s apart from any modern politics or the current catastrophe in Ukraine, I discovered him many years ago and he became one of my favorite Russian-language authors just for Dead Souls and his short stories.
>>24547609
It’s all insanely corrupt. I do apologize, just in a cosmic sense, to no one in particular, for falling for some particularly pro-Russia shilling online.
It’s true though you can bring up a lot of instances, details, conspiracies of NATO and the U.S. having some corrupt involvement in Ukraine, and arguably knowingly wanting to provoke Russia to war with them. But it nevertheless remains that Russia is acting like a particularly brutish and sadistic aggressor here, and, overall, Ukraine isn’t the bigger threat to Russia (at least not as much as Russia is to Ukraine now), and they’re the ones protecting their homeland.
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 2:40:28 AM No.24548006
did op post a twitter convo and expect me to read it
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 2:44:13 AM No.24548015
>>24547889
>The Anglosphere, anything in the EU
Nice bait
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 3:02:50 AM No.24548054
>>24547609
Certain conservatives and tankies from the West hate their own ruling class so deeply that they assume that the negation everything members of that class say is true. If the NYT says Ukraine is good, Ukraine is bad. They want to see their ruling class humiliated, and hope that Russia can accomplish this, which they can't. This is how Russia can simultaneously be perceived as the vanguard of Third Worldism against the evil West and a bastion of Christian conservatism and the white race, people project their beliefs onto Russia hoping that Russia will stick it to people they hate.
Replies: >>24548108
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 3:34:32 AM No.24548108
>>24548054
Yeah. More or less.
They’re in parts justified for railing against the corruption of their own “elites” (so-called, since many of them are really degenerates), but many of them fail to recognize that Russia, with its own elite financial and political class (or oligarchs and the leaders they’re deeply intertwined with) is its own monstrous entity. And has been. Except it’s just that today there’s an apparently different veneer, what with the nominal fall of the USSR and communism.
It’s more like Evil Superpower 1 vs. Evil Superpower 2, than it is either the dogmatic conformist liberal view:
>Well, America and our Western allies of NATO particularly might have some problems in our societies and nations, but Russia is straight up EVIL!;
or, the dissident rightwing view of,
>The Western globohomo regime is totally evil, therefore I support Russia unconditionally since this Western globohomo regime that hates me seems to be against it
Or even the dissident Western leftist view of:
>Its the imperialistic Western NATO axis that’s totally evil, aggressive, militaristic and expansionistic, whereas the Russians are totally valid and justified and responding to such NATO imperialistic expansionist ambitions, and also incidentally part of the axis of Third-Worldism, supporting entities like of BRICS against this Western NATO imperialistic expansionism.

Which is basically me just repeating what you’re saying. But anyway, it seems to be an actual fact, that clever yet corrupt elements of Russia’s ruling elite class and their intelligence agencies have taken on a policy of looking to and trying to infiltrate and persuade both dissident leftist AND rightist elements of the West to get them to support Russia. This has the dual benefit of both fracturing the West and causing more civil tensions and strife among them, AND, of course obviously, getting the propagandized to support Russia or at minimum oppose military action against them or funding and support of any entity they go to war with.

With that said, I still think going to war with Russia as some Western/NATO member who isn’t directly in Eastern Europe or Ukraine being attacked by Russia, is insane. Honestly, some of these leftist, some of these rightwing, and of course some of the Russian fags themselves (the ones majorly responsible for feeding these talking-points and views to such leftwing and right-wing fags of the West) have a point. Regardless, the elite Russians should try to stop being sociopaths and seek some better way to resolve all this, the same way elite Western/NATO fags (and sometimes pedos, Jeffrey-Epstein-style) should’ve been seeking a better way to resolve this the whole time.
Replies: >>24548182 >>24548324
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 4:19:06 AM No.24548182
>>24548108
Nobody outside of Ukraine, barring some mercenaries or volunteers, are actually entering a war with Russia, though, and it's not that insane to send Ukraine weapons at any rate. We shouldn't want a world where countries go around initiating wars of conquest and then threatening to nuke anyone who tries to stop them, which Russia does approximately every 5 minutes. If the US and friends allow this strategy to work, they demonstrate that they are actually cowed by such threats, and that whipping your population into a nationalistic frenzy so that they're perfectly fine with getting nuked if they can't grab the land they want to grab is a viable (and perhaps even good) strategy. The implications of this for China and Taiwan should be obvious.
Replies: >>24548324
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 4:38:45 AM No.24548229
So dosto is not a fascist yah?
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 5:49:38 AM No.24548324
were-all-mad-here-teeturtle
were-all-mad-here-teeturtle
md5: 4b798a4864fda09325e881fbc565f496🔍
>>24546586 (OP)
>Was Dostoyevsky a fascist?
Were the Brothers Grimm Nazis

>>24548108
>But anyway, it seems to be an actual fact, that clever yet corrupt elements of Russia’s ruling elite class and their intelligence agencies have taken on a policy of looking to and trying to infiltrate and persuade both dissident leftist AND rightist elements of the West to get them to support Russia.
They do. I think part of the way they do that by having cutouts working for them who pick up various causes, and then they'll also mix in pro-Russia stuff into the stream. This does work to some extent but it can also backfire because of how cynical and contradictory it is, and also how it runs into conflict (sooner or later) with the reality of Russian policy. Like getting involved in the Palestinian cause is one example and introducing pro-Russian content into that flow, but Russia has reasonably friendly relations with Israel. Or just making predictions that turn out to be totally wrong, which undermines credibility.

I'd add that I don't think they're the only ones who do this. I don't like the Russian government, but I think this sort of thing is pretty common, such as British or American agencies trying to hook into ways to get leftists or rightists to support their interests through various forms of messaging, or get them to form some contradictory coalition. Or how it's done in party politics.

>>24548182
>We shouldn't want a world where countries go around initiating wars of conquest and then threatening to nuke anyone who tries to stop them, which Russia does approximately every 5 minutes.
It's a bipolar and schizo place. There's a military chauvinism in Russia that's very strong and longstanding. It's kind of a cope for living in a poorer and less organized society relative to the Europeans and Japanese and they can glory in that. That side gives me vibes that's like Night of the Living Dead. It's a zombified mentaltiy set to clinky 1970s-style chord progression:
https://youtu.be/c1kdJh4rI9Q

There's also another side that's like the literati, intelligentsia:
https://youtu.be/ylYv1WmqJCQ
Replies: >>24548823
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 5:52:22 AM No.24548329
>>24547202
>Claims the nazis invented anti-semetism
Proceeds to call someone low iq
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 6:07:13 AM No.24548352
>>24546586 (OP)
There’s a Dostoevsky to eating cock pipeline, I’ve noticed.
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 6:25:53 AM No.24548378
They worship Stepan Bandera then say this shit. Truly globohomo kosher nazis
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 11:33:06 AM No.24548823
>>24548324
>Were the Brothers Grimm Nazis
Ja, das ist völkisch, das kann ja so nicht mehr!
Anonymous
7/14/2025, 4:31:28 PM No.24549335
>>24546586 (OP)
he was not