← Home ← Back to /lit/

Thread 24650216

28 posts 6 images /lit/
Anonymous No.24650216 [Report] >>24650218 >>24650229 >>24650271 >>24650273 >>24650298 >>24650621 >>24650681 >>24652697 >>24652816 >>24653778
Has he surpassed Tolkien?
Anonymous No.24650217 [Report] >>24653573
What was Robert's tax policy?
What was Ned's tax policy?
Anonymous No.24650218 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
he who tho?
Anonymous No.24650227 [Report] >>24650253 >>24650272
couldn't even develop the languages he came up with, doesn't even have a creation myth
Anonymous No.24650229 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
Of course not.
Anonymous No.24650240 [Report]
In girth, sure
Anonymous No.24650253 [Report] >>24650316
>>24650227
Forget the languages, his whole theme is "people are bad, mmkay" which he does in a very blatant and uninteresting way. Tolkien portrayed a multitude of themes through his books, he showed us virtue, honor, duty, penance but also corruption, greed and cowardice. Tolkien tries to teach the reader something through his beautiful plots, George R.R Martin is just midwit slop. This thread is a terrible bait.
Anonymous No.24650254 [Report] >>24650315 >>24650683
You know the fact that GRRM has gained the moniker "the American Tolkien" is actually a pretty damning indictment of the United States and its literary culture.
Anonymous No.24650271 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
In producing jew-coded fantasy slop no, in erudtion, also no.
Anonymous No.24650272 [Report]
>>24650227
>muh worldbuilding
Anonymous No.24650273 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
he hasnt even surpassed ur mom in fat
Anonymous No.24650277 [Report] >>24653579
Has OP "has X surpassed Y" type-post surpassed "Y is better than X" type-post ? Has binary comparison surpassed individual enjoyment type-post ? Has Z surpassed both X and Y (comparisons aside) type-post ? Has previous OP to ask repeat question surpassed current OP to ask same type-post ? Has "comparison is the thief of joy" surpassed "X is greater than Y" type-thinking ? Any books for this feel ?
Anonymous No.24650298 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
Tolkien finished his books.
Anonymous No.24650315 [Report]
>>24650254
That title will be stripped the next time something becomes a fad
Anonymous No.24650316 [Report] >>24650837
>>24650253
>his whole theme is "people are bad, mmkay"
That's not even true though. I'm by no means a fan of GRRMs work anymore, I long stopped caring about ASAIF but you clearly never even read those books. Virtue, honor, duty and penance are all themes that are present throughout the story. Many characters are far more nuanced than something you could sum up as "people are bad lmao". There are some 1 dimensional characters who are all evil like Ramsay and Joffrey just like there are some who are all good, like Ned or John Snow, but many of the fan favorite characters like Jaime, Tyrion, Stannis, the Hound, Theon etc are usually the ones who are deeply flawed, who have done bad things for what they thought were the right reasons, but who also went through penance and try to make up for their past mistakes. If there is one thing GRRM does really well, it's that he can write complex, 3 dimensional characters that people can relate to.
Anonymous No.24650621 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
I dunno, I don’t read fat kike books.
Anonymous No.24650681 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
O B S E S S E D
B
S
E
S
S
E
D
Anonymous No.24650683 [Report]
>>24650254
Pretty sure he awarded that moniker to himself.
Anonymous No.24650837 [Report]
>>24650316
Jon Snow isn't all good, he clearly enjoys power and wants to be lord of Winterfell.
Anonymous No.24650858 [Report]
what were gimli's bowel movements like?
Anonymous No.24651873 [Report]
lotr gets talked about more than got and lotr is almost 100 years old
Anonymous No.24652697 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
He shit the bed like King with The Dark Tower. The last two books were complete trash and only a fool would be asking gor more.
Anonymous No.24652806 [Report] >>24653214
>I regard the struggle between good and evil as being waged within the individual human heart. It's not waged as fantasy would have where a character called the dark lord gathers the evil people together and puts them in black clothing, and you know they are evil because they are really ugly and all the good people are handsome and wear white. Very few people get up in the morning and say ''I'm evil, what evil can I do today? I'm going to cover the world with darkness and my legions of evil will rule all.'' That's silly.
what a boring fat fuck
Anonymous No.24652816 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
If he stopped at three books, made Storm of Swords the finale with the intention that this was a slice of interesting world with no explicit beginning or end, and that bad shit happens to good people, maybe you could argue it.

As is, the last two books weren't even good, and it's been 15 years since the latest. He's not even as good as Sanderson, and Sanderson writes slop propped up by the Mormon mafia.
Anonymous No.24653214 [Report]
>>24652806
So LOTR but every character is Boromir?
Got it.
Anonymous No.24653573 [Report]
>>24650217
this
Anonymous No.24653579 [Report]
>>24650277
how it feels to read a combinatorics paper
Anonymous No.24653778 [Report]
>>24650216 (OP)
No.