Why isnt Season 4 your favorite season? - /mlp/ (#42266806) [Archived: 1559 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:42:25 AM No.42266806
images (7) (6)
images (7) (6)
md5: c3e0762062cb2d606d02fd9fb3f4d92e🔍
Season 4:
>Featured by far the most amount of songs of any season of the show, and the songs are consistently great and varied.

>Took risks and was very creative with really fun and varied concepts for episodes.

>Very solid mix of episodes for each of the mane six, plus Spike & the CMC. Every character got great development in at least one episode. All of the characters got great episodes to shine in without exception. (especially impressive is that this season managed to have both two great Spike episodes (Inspiration Manifestation, Equestria Games), and two great CMC episodes (Flight to the Finish, Twilight Time), even though both of those episode types tended to be meh in seasons 1-3.

>Has a more action packed and mature tone, while at the same time not sacrificing any of the characterization and fun that makes the show great (unlike the later seasons).

>The episode quality and consistency is easily the best of any season. Outside of a couple bad episodes and like 3 meh ones, basically everything else was flat out great.

>Twilight was just as nerdy and likeable as before, and her treehouse was still there. She also got great development in the premiere and finale that undid the issues with the rushed Season 3 finale. (Both episodes clearly established how Twilight was not actually very happy with her role as princess, and it took the whole season for her to find her place.) None of the issues with Twilight's character were actually noticeable until Season 5.

>It also fixed the rushed Discord reformation by making it clear in his appearances how he was not fully reformed,was really only even liked by Fluttershy, and still loved annoying others with chaos. These issues built up well to his relapse in the finale, with him realizing that the fun of being evil wasn't worth losing his friendship with Fluttershy. Such great development.

>That season premiere and finale were two of the most fun two-parters of the show. The arc with the keys was a great way to tie the season together in a non-intrusive way that even highlighted great character development.

>Animation quality is probably the best of the entire show, being higher quality compared to the previous seasons while also not trying too hard or seeming stilted like later seasons.

Basically, Season 4 took the great qualities of Seasons 1-3, and pumped up the music, animation, and action, took more risks in general, balanced the characters and developed them fantastically, fixed the issues caused by Season 3, while not sacrificing anything that made the show great previously. It is easily my favorite season for these reasons. Even Season 5 (which I still think was pretty good) began dropping the ball in comparison, and seasons 6-9 basically felt like a whole different (and worse) show.
Replies: >>42266819 >>42266824 >>42266826 >>42266842 >>42266875 >>42267998
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:43:24 AM No.42266807
My waifu barely shows up in it. I gauge my enjoyment primarily off of how much my waifu shows up.
Replies: >>42266812
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:45:43 AM No.42266812
>>42266807
So true
That's why every season is 0/10
Replies: >>42266825
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:47:30 AM No.42266819
>>42266806 (OP)
>anything past season 2
Not canon.
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:48:32 AM No.42266822
>taking text from another thread and making it a standalone
C'mon man.
Replies: >>42266836
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:48:36 AM No.42266824
>>42266806 (OP)
>undid the issues with the rushed Season 3 finale
how lmao
Replies: >>42266898
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:48:36 AM No.42266825
>>42266812
What about 9? Shimmer shows up in the final episode for a few seconds.
Replies: >>42266837
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:49:23 AM No.42266826
1749437113372282
1749437113372282
md5: 8ac8af05d12d58419cab4903a60fc7d6🔍
>>42266806 (OP)
You typed so much yet not only you didn't convince me but also you're also extremely wrong. I feel kinda sad for you, anon
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:54:28 AM No.42266836
7058629
7058629
md5: 3ca53bee593859562ef46d01cc6b2946🔍
>>42266822
i hope youre not actually surprised to see him do it
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:54:43 AM No.42266837
>>42266825
It gets negative points for the child murder so all that does is bring it back to 0/10
Replies: >>42266846
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:56:18 AM No.42266842
>>42266806 (OP)
Is this bait? Like, seems too high effort but most of it is so incorrect I can't see any other explanation.
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 2:57:20 AM No.42266846
>>42266837
Cozyposter, is that you? How have you been old friend?
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 3:09:31 AM No.42266875
>>42266806 (OP)
I feel like season 4 was overall a mixed bag.
It felt like the creators were just throwing ideas at the wall after they learned season 3 wouldn't be the last season and now had to try and figure out how to make the series work going forward.
The worst part about season 4 to me was how they made Twilight Sparkle an overpowered Mary Sue like Ray Skywalker. I personally didn't mind Twilight becoming an alicorn, but I could not excuse Twilight not having any of her character flaws that made her so relatable and iconic to me.
This is a general problem I have with Twilight in seasons 4 and 5 because she was portrayed as absolutely losing her shit if things didn't go according to plan or one thing was out of order. In seasons 4 and 5, things that really should've made her beyond pissed off or hurt ends up making her feel strangely emotionless to it. It just never sat right with me.
I feel like the introduction of Starlight Glimmer was the right step in the direction as I feel like it helps give Twilight Sparkle back her flaws as a character while also introducing a new character to latch on to.
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 3:17:53 AM No.42266898
>>42266824
Season 4 actually showed Twilight feeling mixed about princesshood and taking until the finale for her actually do much of anything with the role and to be satisfied with it. Which undid the issue with the Season 3 finale suddenly putting the role on her without much exploration of it
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 5:52:00 PM No.42267998
>>42266806 (OP)
Twilight has wings in it so it's an instant 0/10
Also the treebrary gets destroyed in the finale so that makes it a -10/10