Perfect 9/10 album once you delete track 4.

That’s the best song. You must be a chud

Why did you make this thread?

>>126744296
Chud wants to seethe about the anti-racist song

Neil should stick to the abstract nursery rhyme songs like Tell Me Why, those are always great--it's when he decides to do a political track for cred purposes that it's like "ah, fuck off already no one cares."

>>126744300
>political track for cred purposes
hippie 60s/70s puss was insane so he had to

>>126744300
if you believe David Crosby he did the political stuff to get attention and never actually believed any of it

>>126744300
>>126744308
>making shit up to fit your chud narrative
yikes. there really is a mental health crisis

>>126744289
>>126744299
>>126744328
Not OP but...
It's self-righteous and pretentious and insists upon itself. It's the longest song on the album by a significant margin.
It does not fit into the rest of the album in terms of style or mood.

>>126744820
>self-righteous and pretentious and insists upon itself
Those are made up critiques. It’s the best song on the album. He has dozens of songs in the same style that are even longer, just admit you don’t like it because he’s calling slavery bad. It’s not hard to figure out why you are seething

>>126744858
>Those are made up critiques.
All critiques are made up. These were made up by me, just now.
>It’s the best song on the album.
Completely subjective. I would say Tell Me Why, the title track, Only Love Can Break Your Heart, Birds, and I Believe in You are all way better. They have an ethereal magic that is truer to the spirit of the overall album and is completely missing in Southern Man.
>He has dozens of songs in the same style that are even longer
On other albums.
>just admit you don’t like it because he’s calling slavery bad.
If Cowgirl in the Sand or Down by the River were on here they would be equally out of place.
That being said, the way he goes about calling slavery bad is indeed cringe. I wouldn't want to listen to someone yelling about how abortion or white genocide is evil for 6 minutes either.

Southern Man has the best guitar work on the album

>>126744960
That's cause it has the only guitar work on the album.

>>126744951
A lot of his albums feature his range of songwriting, you are just seething over the slavery=bad song

>>126744977
>teleports behind you
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUnyuYPth5Q

>>126744987
>A lot of his albums feature his range of songwriting
yeah, and none of them are perfect
Zuma is close
And guess what, that has another white guilt song
But it works there

>>126744977
There’s guitar on every song but one

>>126745008
two, actually

>>126745006
So you only get butthurt when Neil sings about social issues that you are on the wrong side of. Interesting

lol why is a Canadian singing about US politics anyway?

>>126745016
Where did I imply I was pro-slavery or anti-conquistador

>>126745017
He’s an American

>>126745037
bruh

>>126745042
Yes he’s a Canadian and an American you dumb retard

>>126745017
side effect of BDE

HEY HEY
MY MY

>>126745046
He became a US citizen 5 years ago
He released Southern Man 55 years ago

Don't let it bring you down, OP.

>>126745066
And he lived here for years before releasing the song

>>126745075
https://youtu.be/awp-wud531g?&t=86

>>126744960
I can't say I super love the guitar on there it's just...ok.

How did this MF sing so high?

The song worked as far as getting attention+critical points because otherwise nobody'd notice an album of abstract stoner ditties or have much to write about it.

>>126745131
Meh that's nothing compared to Rob Halford.

>>126745104
tell us something we don't know, professor
>>126745131
he's a tenor

>>126745131
he clearly just has a really high-placed voice like Geddy Lee

>>126744276 (OP)
His new album is so bad. Neil should stop writing new songs and just keep mining the archive.

>>126744300
"The Needle and the Damage Done" because it was about a very real problem that affects a lot of people as opposed to meaningless white guilt.

>>126745302
Racism is still a problem that affects people. Keep seething chud

Another album that comes to mind that would be perfect with one song removed (If you've heard it you know which one it is)

>>126745324
>Racism is still a problem that affects people.
Yeah. White people lmao

>>126745334
Lemme guess, the song about immigration. Wow. Keep on chudding chudfag

>Perfect 9/10 album once you delete track 4.
Houses of the Holy

>>126745302
we've probably all had friends or family members who were lost to drugs but i can't say i ever knew anyone who was whipped on a slave plantation. actually no one has unless somehow they're 170 years old.

>>126745131
There was a band playin' in his head and he felt like singing high

>>126744820
It just sounds good, and it comes from the heart. Get over yourself.

>>126745439

>>126744276 (OP)
Leaking Clittycell thread

>>126745017
why is an american commenting on the actions of a canadian?