>>126761329 (OP) It tends to be the case for a lot of 2000s emo/scene stuff. I listened to pic related for the first time a couple years ago having only heard the singles as a kid. Those singles were still fun, the rest was pretty crap.
>>126762755 I mean, I wouldn't go that far. Take This To Your Grace is their only completely perfect album. Cork Tree, while great, has a couple songs I would have left off. Or maybe I got really burned out from their singles back in the day. Infinity is great but definitely where cracks started to show and there's a lot of filler on it.