Are artists that the internet hates by coincidence popular with girls, or are these musicians hated by the internet ~because~ they're popular with girls?

No one hates them but slimy millenial losers who are not popular with the girls

Society hated pop punk and emo because it sucked and was so obviously fake/manufactured that it actually united normies with metalheads & goths whenever it came to dunking on the fans. The demographic for these kinds of bands were all failed normies who suddenly became alternative over the summer, and nobody really bought that they were being sincere. It had nothing to do with whether women liked the bands or not.

>>126763048
True.

>>126763041
Projection.

>>126763041
True.

>>126763048
>>126763054
Projection.

>>126763041
eat a dick, cunt

>>126763068
feel free to prove me wrong, because I know for sure you're a incel on your 30s that not a single person likes

>>126763041
>>126763066
Samefag.

>>126763048
>>126763054
>>126763068
Unique posters.

>>126763048
I am positive that Justin Bieber would have never gotten that much disrespect on the internet if he wasn't on every girl's phone lockscreen in the early 2010s.

>>126763048
Three Cheers and Bullets are better and more honest than your favorite album and your entire life

>>126762979 (OP)
>Shitty corporate mallcore pop punk
>Why does everyone hate them?
Do you need me to explain why most people hate shit too?

>>126763066
There are entire south park episodes making fun of this exact societal phenomenon.

>>126763048
trvthnvke

>>126763166
what the fuck is corporate about MCR? The fact they got popular? Only I'm Not Okay is pop punk

>>126763169
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OvUDHpPgb4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rYZUEl1q6qQ

>>126763169
>>126763194
??????
Is Jew Park your gospel or something?
The fact people who dressed like this liked them has nothing to do with the quality of the music, MCR didn't even embrace this aesthetic unlike other screamo acts of the time

>>126763121
Maybe so, but other prettyboys had come and gone in pop and didn't inspire so much ire. Bieber was just the next iteration of a Tiger Beat idol. They tried to launch Jesse McCartney just a few years earlier, girls loved him but no guy even knew he existed. It's probably the fact that Bieber was among the first pop stars to blow up mostly online. Gaga also blew up online and had a similar backlash early on, with the endless tranny jokes.

>>126763216
> the quality of the music
...what quality? melodrama? the same pretty boy falsetto that every other pop punk & screamo artist used? a bunch of songs with shitty drum parts and boring basslines? absolutely no groove? no edge?

>>126763271
>a bunch of songs with shitty drum parts and boring basslines? absolute no groove?
nvm, you are a niggerbrained monkey, you would never get it

>>126762979 (OP)
Can we ban this guy already

>>126763338
Idk it's funny to see him get so rectum ravaged in every thread.

>>126763338
I also agree

mod deleted my post xd

I don't take anything that I said back, anyone that uses the word ''melodrama'' is a demeaning way is a soulless monkey

>>126763596
Bro, think about the time period that band operated during. They wrote boohoo I wanna kill myself lyrics during a time where most "dark-coded" alternative music was about overthrowing the government, discovering esoteric secrets, or standing in total opposition to society. The handful of (non-emo) artists that made music about suicide also wrote music about homicide or other forms of externalized rebellion and angst.

>>126763662
they literally didn't you fucking mongoloid, yes there were a lot of artists like that at that time but their music was the opposite, it's 100% campy and fun post hardcore with a edge to it, there's not a single sad song about wanting to commit suicide or about how everything sucks for the sake of wallowing on misery, the closest thing to that is cancer because it's part of a concept album of someone literally dying of cancer, but that album is also bright and positive, that's why they are special and stand above the others to this day, please for the love of god go actually listen to them

>>126763048
Spbp

>>126763741
another braindead reply while still no one can answer to >>126763188
My Chemical Romance was great and that's why they keep getting listeners
but no one is really losing anything by you idiots staying ignorant

>>126763729
bro i saw them live once, they sucked dick.

>>126763991
when?

>>126764001
2004, during Green Day's American Idiot tour.

>>126764006
everything you said about them is still untrue

>>126764015
> seething
Emo will never have been for pathological nonconformists & free-thinkers. Sorry. It was for giant pussies and bpd hoes.

>>126764032
This is mall emo too. Absolute garbage

>>126764032
why would I be seething by the fact you were born a braindead retard? you went to one of their show and still think they wrote boo hoo I wanna kill myself music, things go inside our ear but have the same effect as if you were deaf, this would be a bother in my life if I was one of your parents

>>126764066
>Absolute garbage
pure projection

>>126764067
>why would I be seething
>seethes uncontrollably
time to go outside lil bro

>>126764067
You're such a neurotic little pussy. Typical emo kid!

>>126763121
I think it was more to do with his breakout song going
>baaaby baaaby baaaby ooohhhhh
it was just really annoying lol

>>126764121
All he had to do was wear hollister & work at abercrombie & fitch, and he could have taken becky babybangs to prom. but she said no, he got cut from the football team, and now he wears black nail polish.

>>126764142
>>126764149
This would've been funny if it wasn't for the fact you two are over 30, so it's really fucking grim

>>126764170
> mad that we're the exact age all the gen Z bpd hoes want to date to fulfill their weird daddy fetishes
> also likes emo music

damn son

>>126764192
You're a disgusting loser no one would want to date even with a gun to their heads

>>126762979 (OP)
When these guys were big the only girls into them were fucking ugly

>>126763121
This is true and people are extra angry and hateful about shit that preteen and teen girls like, but MCR hate wasn't really about that. It was just the forefront of the popification, commercialization, and bastardization of alternative shit, the same shit kids were getting beat up or teased for was now cool and popular pretty suddenly and it was completely normal to see the cool kids in school imitating the styles and aesthetics and then mixing them with hello kitty shit. It was "alternative" and "punk" that you could literally buy at the mall in an afternoon, no more ethos attached. Stuff like MCR, Paramore, and Avril Lavigne were just a particularly blatant example of a gentrified movement, complete with grifters in every direction. They brought "punk" to kids. MCR pissed people off especially because they had some dude fans that tried to legitimize them while detractors insisted they were no different from the girly kiddie stuff like Avril or Paramore.
Everything is like this now, where we have reduced lifestyles and youth movements to surface level aesthetics that you can put on like a costume, no context required, so this all probably seems like a non-issue.
Hard to find an equivalent now since I don't think rejects or dorks in school get together and kind of create their own thing in the first place.

>>126764233
i fucked a big tiddy latina raw for 4 years. im good.

>>126764289
Fucking is not dating, you are as worthy as a rubber toy

>>126763781
Hahahahahah zoomie cope. Mcr were never good, that's why we bullied people who listened to that garbage

>>126764352
Is that why you seethe about them to this day and you will die and be forgotten by everyone and they will not even though they were just a "trend"? hmmmm I see I see

>>126764364
Look around retard, the only one seething here is (You)

>>126764382
If seething is just pointing out reality to a bunch of old losers at an imageboard who shouldn't even be here in the first place but are because they failed at everything in life, sure, I guess I am indeed seething

>>126762979 (OP)
Most truly terrible artists with male audiences are totally ignorable (Lil Darkie comes to mind) meanwhile, if women really like someone's music, it automatically ends up all over everywhere whether it be good or outright horrid.

>>126764382
I just know you're a greasy fat metalhead lmao

>>126763188
>The fact they got popular?
Yes. Mainstream popularity for music artists since the 1996 deregulation of radio has been dictated by large, consolidation mega corporations who own every station in the US and collude with each other to push whatever sound they demand. Notice how in 2000 all of the good bands completely faded out and got replaced with bubblegum trash like Britney and NSYNC. If you were on pop radio past 2000, it's because you sucked a rich guy's dick to get there.

>>126764512
you are just a fucking idiot

>>126764344
and yet, it is you who types like a floppy little dildo.

>>126764512
>>126764566
Do you not know what the Telecommunications Act of 1996 was?

>>126764617
what does that even mean

>>126764344
simp cuck faggot ahh nigga

>>126764628
that you talk like a fag and you're shit's retarded.

holy shit this mcrsperg really is insufferable

The Black Parade [Reprise, 2006]
In prog, a good sense of humor means so much ("Teenagers," "Dead!"). **

>>126762979 (OP)
they sucked and the people who liked them sucked. they represent the complete commodification of anything alternative as others have said. slop for theater kids

>>126764752
>commodification
is that why there are no other band that sounds like them?

>>126764752
61stpbp

>>126762979 (OP)
nu-metal has never been stereotyped as music for women, but it was widely hated nonetheless.

>>126764773
literally any pop punk band can be interchanged with them. Why does no band sound like royal true?

>>126764799
then please post those pop punk songs that sounds like this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uPMDRsH1YRU

or this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gyu_hqpxj8M

because I love this songs so much and I would like to hear more like it but I still haven't found anything that compares

>>126764829
I wouldn't waste my time on a crap genre for theater kids, sorry. How about listening to black metal or noise rock for actual edge?

holy shit this anti-mcrsperg really is insufferable

>>126764930
lmao couldn't prove your point, so just bitches out instead. classic.

>>126764170
How old do you think this site is?

>>126764975
wow you don't want to drink liquid shit you must be a pussy!

>>126764829
https://youtu.be/5eZGRgHqbLw?si=JKNli7kc3PwV8ONi

https://youtu.be/vaQ_Csbrt8M?si=2B6EAfbDU-xkET34

https://youtu.be/N5QD343N3IU?si=ZZ0YlNB9EpuveKSC

>>126764930
>theater kids
what even is this insult
what's wrong with liking theater as a kid

>>126765018
I don't like any of these

>>126765035
thats cause ur gay

>>126765020
imagine a normie but completely up their own ass and insufferable

>>126765039
you?

>>126765018
based pg 99 enjoyer

>>126765050
I don't enjoy slop music or malls so nice try. Maybe make this thread on reddit

>>126764930
>lists two of the cringiest and gayest genres around
Yeesh

>>126765079
well, having zero self awareness is part of it

>>126762979 (OP)
Pretty sure they're hated here because you post about them constantly. Same with the Cobain faggots.

>>126765090
>absolute cope

>>126765110
They're both embarrassing as hell. It's no better than the shit you're arguing about.

I declare this the MCR general

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpvG3DsWm8o

>>126763662
>the handful of (non-emo) artists that made music about suicide also wrote music about homicide
Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge is literally about homicide, do your research next time, pseud.
>other forms of externalized rebellion and angst.
They also have a whole album about dismantling a dystopian government.'
>boohoo I wanna kill myself lyrics
That's just proof that you've never actually listened to them and just basing your assumptions to the stereotypical view of mcr that normies hold. Opinion discarded.
Nirvana: I hate my life and want die
MCR: I'm not afraid to keep on living.

>>126762979 (OP)
define Internet because I don't see anyone actively hating on MCR other than pretentious niche music forums

>>126765403
You suck and this band is awful

>>126763188
They're no more corporate than the average mainstream rock band.

>>126765419
most people disagree
but also most people agree you suck because no one likes you
connect the dots and find truth

>>126765419
What an intelligent rebuttal.

>>126764269
>It was just the forefront of the popification, commercialization, and bastardization of alternative shit
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mGgMZpGYiy8
The most famous goth band made literal romcom music way before Gerard Way witnessed 9/11 and conceived mcr..

>>126763121
Didn’t he say shit like “rap and hip hop loves me, i’m basically one of them” or something like that? JB basically turned every rap fan against him instantly.

>>126762979 (OP)
After seeing every genre of music become absorbed by hip hop I'm sorry I ever criticized forms of rock and pop that did not personally appeal to me

>>126764798
This. If anything it was THE macho, dudebro genre around ~2000

>>126764246
Zoomie here (23) who grew up way after the heyday of this stuff and even I know this is absolutely true.
There were always a handful of girls at highschool or college who fangirled over MCR and similar bands (despite mcr having disbanded years prior) and they were ALWAYS fat as fuck. I have no idea why, i never associated emo shit with fatsos desu

>>126766005
Oh yeah, the band that came out the gate with Boys Don't Cry really sold out. What point are you even trying to make?

>>126766005
The Cure have always been all over the place musically. It's why they have maybe 4 good albums and the rest is okay at best.