https://x.com/pitchfork/status/1937299732424188091
>the seething in the replies
kek

>>126838598 (OP)
giving Guns n Roses a 10 is like giving Mc Donalds a 10

maybe the nostalgiatards who want their 40yo bands to keep releasing banger after banger after all this time should take it easy and think the skepticism is warranted

hell, I want einsturzende neubauten to still be cool, but they're old, mellowed-out coots, now.

>>126838640
Deserved!

its one of the greatest hard rock albums of all time. if you are seething you just hate rock music

PITCHFORK IS REDEEMED

WE HAVE A NEW DAWN

AXLBROS... WE WON

https://youtu.be/WXCuDK5smxM

>>126838598 (OP)
it is a 10, you would think with how big poptimism is now that people would understand that people like GnR because it's just chaotic, well performed, catchy music, but because it's "macho" younger people don't want to admit that this type of music still has a lot of merit. I don't mean this in a chuddy way, I understand why a lot of younger people don't want to feel as restricted by societal norms, but seeing so many indie kids desperately try to shit on a lot of older metal acts always comes off as pathetic

>>126838848
>PITCHFORK IS REDEEMED
the review is from 8 years ago

>>126838880
Oh so they just reposted it on twitter to generate hate-clicks? Pretty cheap

I thought /mu/ said P4K are just woke shills and joos

>>126838598 (OP)
Chinese Democracy is better than this heaping pile of shit

Time to post Axl's ass in celebration.

>>126838906
GnR are also on their tour right now

>>126838920
Is that a guy whom Kurt Cobain called homophobic?

>>126838935
yeah

>>126838598 (OP)
Bunch of soft hipster faggots crying in the replies

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEHE--1no-k

>>126838912
Horrible contrarian opinion

>>126839029
not contrarian, just factual

>>126838640
As they should.

>>126838912
HOLY BASED

Better is a MASTERPIECE

>>126839144
It's not true at all. Maybe you guys are just burned out on Appetite. But it's one great song after another. Very few albums like that.

>>126838598 (OP)
What's with the seething? Not many of them give reasons other than seething

>>126838598 (OP)
>a review from 2017

>>126839333
they haven't even listened to it, they just hate Gnr off the rip cause they are white and make rock music

>>126841537
Slash is half black though. kek

>>126839333
millennials (pbut) hating on GNR but zoomers being like could I cop Axl's look and does it go with my mustache?

>>126838920
>>126838943
>>126838983
People act like this is gay, meanwhile the whole front row in every photo is women staring at them with sopping wet pussies.

>>126841553
well i doubt they know that either

>>126839333
A lot of indie snob millennials and zoomzooms hate GnR for being "toxic macho cockrock garbage". Seems like Pitchfork got over that but at least on RYM you can see many reviews fixate on that judgement

>>126838598 (OP)
Better than any Nirvana album in my books

>>126841654
Apart from the time Axl wore this to a frat party, you'd be correct

From the band's photographer:
https://www.mygnrforum.com/topic/202724-gnr-style/#findComment-3558989

>Yes the Girls loved it and the Guys were grossed out

>>126838598 (OP)
WE'VE BEEN DANCING WITH MR. BROWNSTONE

van halen and zeppelin did hard rock much better

>>126838598 (OP)
heterosexuality is back on the menu

i didn't grow up on radio or boomer rock parents so sweet child o mine still sounds amazing and not overplayed

Drink your s o y

>>126838640
In 1987 they were both 10's.

>>126841553
Slashfacts:
Slash's mom, Ola Hudson is black. She was the costume designer for the 1976 film The Man Who Fell To Earth, starring David Bowie. Ola was also Bowie's gf at the time.

>>126838912
Get well soon.

>>126838640
>giving Guns n Roses a 10 is like giving Mc Donalds a 10
Axles is a huge fan of their work.

>>126838598 (OP)
zoomers HATE this band because it isn't "vibes" music.

>>126838846
Fuck yeah dude keep rawking

>>126845684
I'm a zoomer and I like them because of Guitar Hero 2 and 3

>>126841820
Why do people care about this? Why does this matter so much. Is it just loser sjw with no life and no job who just want to complain 24/7 about people not acting like a complete faggot?

>>126845684
They don’t understand AC/DC and back in black too, fuck em