Niggas be like, yeah we'll put a goofy ass song with an annoying dog barking, then right after we'll go with the greatest piece of prog ever written. Truly the GOAT band.

>>127017323 (OP)
>greatest piece of prog ever written
That's not Moonchild.

>>127017355
Great first 3 minutes, can easily live without the rest

>>127017323 (OP)
Seamus is such a bad song, instant skipper. I cant believe Floyd didnt have anything better than that in the back catalog to use.

>>127017323 (OP)
>>127017557
I like Seamus, it’s comfy because it reminds me of being at a farm.

>>127017371
what? don't you like soothing ambience anon?

St Tropez is another silly song, that and seamus wreck the whole feel of the album

>>127017355
most of it is aimless noodling

>>127017323 (OP)
Actually it wouldnt be right after because you'd have to turn over the vinyl :) echoes took up its own side :)

>>127017571
I do, but that part of Moonchild is so out of place for that album.

>>127017982
How dare you

>>127017323 (OP)
Unfunny zoomer wigger faggot

I would rather keep seamus and st tropez on the album and get rid of echoes. Prog concept songs and albums ruined floyd

>50 years later and people are still filtered by Seamus
Sovl song

>>127017323 (OP)
haven't scrolled the thread yet. 90% chance someone is defending seamus as some underrated gem

>>127022400
i was right

>>127017323 (OP)
man why you gotta complain about Seamus (that's the dog)?
He's not annoying, he's a woogum. I hope they gave him some bacon.

Atom Heart Mother mogs
>>127017355
Larks, and Starless mog

also if you like rush Cygnus X1>2112

>>127020349
he likes echoes and thats enough to deserve to meet him in the middle

Best live performances on YouTube?
Already watched Pompeii and Wembley '74.

>>127017619
I kind of agree as much as I hate to because I do love the album. San tropez makes even less sense than Seamus. Seamus is some silly joke but San tropez is like... steely dan? Not sure why we needed floyd to do that style

>>127023388
the truth i that Floyd were aimless hacks until DSOTM when they decided to be actual songwriters. don't get me wrong, pre Dark Side produced some great stuff but there was an equal amount of things were only made because they didn't know for sure what they wanted to make.

>>127024530
At least they got there in the end through sheer effort

>>127017323 (OP)
echoes is the worst song on the album

>>127025295
contrarian