The great debate
which band is best?
which has the best albums?
and the best overall discography?
who are the greatest musicians?
state your thoughts

>>127096752 (OP)
Best singer: John
Best guitarist: Hackett
Best drummer: Phil
Best bassist: Chris
Best keyboardist: Rick
Best keyboard sounds: Tony

>>127096786
>tfw you'll never have a prime 70s era GeneYes collaboration album

>>127096786
>Best guitarist: Hackett
doesn't hold a candle to Howe
he's the greatest prog guitarist, only rivaled in skill by Holdsworth

>>127096752 (OP)
Yes is more consistent but Genesis has the higher highs.

>>127096786
in what universe is Collins better than Bruford?
>>127096889
I don't see how they'd blend their styles really
Yes's music is more contemplative
Genesis's is more theatrical

>>127096992
other way around for me
yes's best albums are peak prog
yes's worst albums are absolute trash