Honestly, if you consider it objectively and from a weighted, completely component-based perspective, do you agree it was the greatest album of the 2000s?

>>127110650 (OP)
Definitely top 10 greatest albums of the 2000s not a doubt, anyone who says otherwise, is either deaf, a contrarian, has shitty taste, or is jealous.

>Definitely top 10 greatest albums of the 2000s not a doubt, anyone who says otherwise, is either deaf, a contrarian, has shitty taste, or is jealous.

>>127110829
astonishingly based

Samefag thread

>>127110650 (OP)
if green day and queen had an abortion

mogged by Danger Days the greatest power pop album of the last 30 years

>>127111175
Is the Animaterr Man in the room with us right now?

>>127110650 (OP)
Give it a fucking rest

>>127111707
This

>>127110650 (OP)
I get nothing out of this band. I like Panic! but this just sounds like a relic of an era to me. Being timestamped alone doesn't make something bad, it just has to be better than this. There is a far better album that was released on the same exact day as this one.

>>127111824
It's one faggot here who makes this same thread over and over again. No one believes this shit but him.

>>127111843
there's plenty of people who agree lmao cope harder. MCR is still as popular as ever and is getting the recognition they deserve, get over it

>>127111914
Yet only one faggot here makes these thread and it's you. And what do you mean recognition they deserve? They were immensely successful in their time. You're just obnoxious.

>>127111937
seek medical attention, legitimately. You don't have to suffer like this. Get help

>>127111983
>projection

>>127111983
Address anything I said, asshole. You like the album? Good for you. Go fucking listen to it and quit with the "pound for pound, revolutionary, world changing" horse shit you're always on about.

>>127111914
Keep making these threads, the seethe it causes is hilarious.

>>127111780
>>127111707
>>127111175
>>127111843
>>127111937
>>127112007
samefag schizo

>>127112158
samefag

>>127112007
Sorry you're upset? Not really sure why Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge being the greatest album, collectively, after considering all the different elements both on their own and as a whole (which would be too numerous to name here itt and honestly deserves its own separate thread/discussion), of the 2000s is so problematic for you? Where did I say there aren't other incredible albums of the 2000s? You're fighting with yourself dude, quit punching the air and go outside or something idk

>>127112191
>You're fighting with yourself dude, quit punching the air and go outside or something idk
more projection from this annoying samefag

>>127112232
You seem really flustered, maybe find something else to do. Stress is bad for your health.

>>127112244
there he goes, projecting again

>>127112167
Yeah a bunch of those are me because we're having an argument you dumb fuck. What do you think that proves?
>>127112191
MCR isn't anything special and you should kill yourself for rambling on and on and trying to make them seem important. You're as bad as Nicosperg but at least he could be entertaining. You're just a faggot with shit taste.

>>127112253
>>127112267
samefag

>>127112277
Nope. But keep trying to dance around the subject, faggot.

>>127112267
This guy gets it. Mcrschizo is like nicofag but more obnoxious and pathetic
>>127112277
you can’t even copy anons correctly you dumb fag

>this guy gets it
>projection

>>127112267
I don't even know who Nicosperg is. The fact that you know pointless autistic knowledge like that suggests you may in fact be a sperg as well. You do know you can leave threads, don't you? And yet here you remain, screaming at ghosts, trying to knock out oxygen and negatively impacting your health.

>>127112318
go back newfag

i could name 20 better albums from the 00s easily but I'll just leave this one
>Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavored Water

>>127112330
Yup. Somehow limp bizkit holds up way better than this awful poser faggot music

>>127112318
Don't know Nicosperg? You should lurk more then. You might become entertaining instead of being an obnoxious fucking faggot who makes the same thread a billion times a week.

>>127112330
>>127112340
Limp Bizkit and Chocolate Starfish are definitely deserving of a reappraisal and greater recognition, but it's not consistent all the way through like Three Cheers.

>go back newfag

>>127112294
>>127112267
Retard samefagging retarded copypastes from fantano fanboys ?, you're pathetic. That albums mogs 90% of rock albums from the 2000s not only due to the cheer the versatility of sounds, and memorable/catchy tunes, but for influencing a new style of music, something nearly no other rock album did at the time, which were relying on doing what was already popular at the time to reach success.

>>127112364
How many Black Parade funkos do you have in your bussy right now?

>>127110650 (OP)
That albums mogs 90% of rock albums from the 2000s not only due to the sheer versatility of sounds, and memorable/catchy tunes, but for influencing a new style of music, something nearly no other rock album did at the time, which were relying on doing what was already popular to attain success.

>>127112407
Kys

>>127112444
Trips of truth

>>127112444
>>127112460
samefag

>>127112466
>projection

>>127112478
he said the line!

>>127112466
Those are the rules. Anon got trips. You gotta kill yourself and be buried in your Black Parade marching band outfit.

>>127112488
Great idea

>>127112488
>projection

>>127112514
You desperately need new material

>>127112528
This guy gets it.

MCRtranny is melting down

kek

>>127112538
>t. pathetic samefag

>>127112557
Keep melting mcrcow lmao

>>127112569
>projection

>>127112569
>he's in every single MCR thread on the board
Kek. Doing it to yourself. You must secretly like the arguments or something idk why else youd be stalking literally every MCR thread on this board

>>127112592
See >>127112528

>>127112632
There's no need for any band to be discussed this much. Especially one as unremarkable as MCR. Hate to break it to you.

>>127112653
then why are you in this thread?

>>127112653
Yup. The samefaggotry is unreal

>>127112662
Because fuck you and the countless threads you trannies feel the need to make about this middle of the road band.

>>127112653
it's literally a board dedicated to music discussion are you high lmao

>>127112676
but you said the band doesn't need to be discussed this much but you are spending a lot of time discussing and thinking about this band.

>>127112682
MCR isn't music. 'fraid so.
>>127112683
Not really. This is more about you and your shit taste and making you meltdown.

>>127112676
>>127112669
>trannieS
Thanks for admitting there are many people here, and it isn't "samefagging", not trannies tho, but you're a retarded samefagging anon.

>>127112713
You wanna give that sentence another go, champ?

>>127112706
No one is melting down, except your last brain cells, having listened to your shitty music taste for so long. 1 MCR song has more talent in it than your favorite band in their whole catalog.

>>127112738
You wanna try that response again without crying, champ?

>>127112706
>This is more about you and your shit taste and making you meltdown.
But ultimately, you are discussing MCR. Don't you have better things to do?

>>127112753
No, chump, you and your "arguments" are too dumb, and your music taste too shitty, for any meaningful discussion

>>127112756
It's Sunday so I suppose I could pray that you will get over your Gerard Way lust but I think we both know there's no point to that.

>>127112773
I will go ahead and accept your concession then

>>127112738
I'd love to hear what bands he likes and his pick for greatest 2000s album, kek. Probably some faggy cringey edgelord shit like QoTSA or something

>>127112800
>MCRtranny thinking he can talk about anyone's music taste
KEK

>>127112821
I know you have none, so I can't talk about yours, chump. But since you dont like mcr, any music you do like is bound to be the worst crap of all though.

>>127112873
See >>127112821
You're never gonna recover from that

>>127112873
>>127112800
That's 2 different people you imbecile...

>>127112897
Sure they are, champ

>>127112886
That's 2 different people, you imbecile.

>>127112910
Doesn't make anything I said less true, faggot

>>127112909
>>127112921
Talking to yourself shit-for-brains ?, you're so boring and dumb, you're scaring other anons away. You're bad at your work as a clown.

>>127110650 (OP)
Hmmm... No.

>>127112952
MCRTranny going full Chernobyl kek

>>127110650 (OP)
no. mcrfag kys

>78 replies to ancient spam
thought you guys were better than this

Three Cheers is FLCL, but the Black Parade is Evangelion

MCR is one of the worst bands of all time

>>127113896
true but could also be said about literally any other 2000's band

>>127113908
Libertines actually rocked

>>127113908
Nope. MCR is gay cringe

>>127113928
If Gerard Way hurt you just say that, no need to project on /mu/

>>127110650 (OP)
It's good but I prefer The Black Parade.

>>127113928
>MCR is gay cringe
i agree but the same could be said about literally any other 2000's band

enough already

you guys just gave MCR spammer all the motivation they need to keep spamming for the next decade

>>127110871
>top 10 greatest albums of the 2000s
that's like making it to the top of a mountain of shit

>>127110650 (OP)
>see MCR thread
>90 replies
>"ah they must be talking about their huge ongoing stadium tour"
>no, it's the mcr hater schizo again...

>>127116266
You are the schizo. Let your dogshit samefag thread die you massive faggot

>>127116276
This was my first reply, go to sleep schizo.

>>127116520
nice try samefag

>>127116541
Just because were samefagging all night doesn't mean that everyone else is a samefag too. Do you ever sleep?

>>127117585
Do you?

>>127117643
Yes, I was asleep during your meltdown.

>>127116266
>spam several MCR threads every single day
>if you hate that you are the schizo one

>>127117875
If you really wanted the threads to die you'd stop engaging and baiting the MCRfags to reply back. Simple as.

>>127117924
This guy gets it.

>>127117924
He (not so) secretly enjoys it. That's the only real explanation

>>127117875
>projecting

>>127116276
This

>>127113928
>t. has a PhD in gay cringe

>>127111188
Danger days sucked ass

>>127118354
how?
>Bulletproof Heart
>Sing
>The Only Hope For Me Is You
>Save Yourself, I'll Hold Them Back
>Scarecrow
>Summertime
>Destroya
>The Kids From Yesterday
All are great songs

>>127110650 (OP)
>Best early to mid 2000s albums
>No repeat artists and not in order
3CFSR - MCR
Hot Fuss - The Killers
Songs for the Deaf - QOTSA
Elephant - The White Stripes
Lateralus - Tool
Bleed American - J.E.W.
GNFPWLBN - Modest Mouse
O - Damien Rice
Relationships of Command - At the Drive-In
Watch Out - Alexisonfire
By The Way - RHCP
Is This It - The Strokes
Blink 182 - Blink 182
De-Loused in the Comatorium - The Mars Volta

>>127110650 (OP)
Thursday's Full Collapse is the best most important album of the 2000s.

>>127118478
>No repeat artists and not in order
>At The Drive in and Mars Volta in the same list
You tried to be sneaky.

>>127118523
I did hesitate to put The Mars Volta in. I was in a band with a guy who insisted Sparta were better than the Mars Volta and that made me there's enough difference in creative members to justify it. If I had to pick between the two it would be ATDI though.

>>127118478
Blink, JEW, ATDI, Alexisonfire are all infinitely better and more influential than MCR
>>127118501
This too. Thursday's importance is immense. But MCRtranny doesn't wanna hear it.

>>127118573
Better is subjective. Blink are probably the only ones more influential than MCR. Not that being influential matters at all to how much anyone enjoys something. Retarded self appointed critic logic there.
Also they were pretty much the last generation of rock bands. Their overall legacy is the death of rock.
Not that it had anything to do with the artists, it was all to do with economics, technology, and top-down programming decisions.

>>127118613
Nah. Jimmy Eat World are definitely better than MCR and anyone with functioning ears will tell you that. Nice cope though.

>>127118630
Crazy take
>>127118573
Thursday was very influential but they aren't better than MCR

>>127118646
Not crazy at all. Jimmy Eat World are fucking legends and got over doing shit their own way despite being fucked over.
>>127118646
Yes. They are. MCR will never have anything as important as Full Collapse or WATT.

>>127118630
I have functioning ears, I don't need someone to tell me.
MCR are more technically accomplished musicans than JEW, not that that really matters to how much anyone enjoys their work.

>>127118670
Jesus Christ

>>127118676
Praise his name

>>127118744
Nah. Even he thinks you're retarded. He loves you all the same but even He can't forgive that trash opinion.

>>127118390
some of those, arguably yeah. but sing? way to blow your credibility.

>>127118784
The worst gig I ever paid for was Jimmy Eat World in 2005

>>127118646
>Thursday was very influential but they aren't better than MCR
Only if you meassure art through commercial success. Thursday's an outright better band. MCR never made good songs as You Were The Cancer

>>127119072
People have bad shows all the time. Doesn't change the fact that JEW are a legendary band and infinitely more talented than MCR
>>127119097
Based Thursday Chad

>>127110650 (OP)
damn this thread blew up. Looks like MCR has some serious staying power

>>127119072
JEW is probably the only who could try to compete with MCR, but would lose all the same. Blink 182 is just boring/cringe 90s punk, lackluster to a T.
>best emo/punk rock bands
MCR 10/10
JEW 8.5/10
TBS 8.5/10
BN 8.5/10
TU 8/10
DBC 8/10
HH 8/10
SDRE 7.5/10
B182 7/10
Thursday 6.5/10

>>127119201
Brand New is a 6.5 at the absolute most, more like a 6. They're insanely overrated

>>127119201
TBS above Brand New tells us everything we need to know about you and your retarded opinions.

>>127119233
Their albums are a mixed bag, some awesome songs mixed with boring long ones... if you took the fillers out, they'd be an 8.5/10, with the fillers, a 7.5/10, only the fillers, a 4/10

>>127119201
Incredibly idiotic, I am actually convinced you are baiting, that or you think MCR are better simply because they are the most acessible out of these.
For all their career MCR wrote simplified Pop versions of what came prior, first they were just simplifying Thursday's sound as everyone else was at the time, then they hyper-focused on the theatrics, Glam Rock influences with Black Parade, yet aftewards, unlike Thursday, they had nowhere left to go hence why their next album was an absolute crapshoot of doubling down on Glam.
Don't get me wrong, what they did, they did well, but acting like MCR is the best "Emo" band is an opinion born out of arrogance and refusal to approach music that dares to stray away from Verse-Chorus formula.
I agree with the anons prior, JEW are much better just due to Clarity alone, all your opinions about MCR being better technical players doesn't matter to me as they never wrote songs as rich, layered nor interesting as For Me This Is Heaven, they never dared to move away from radio-ready music, their music is fun but not adventurous.
Even when JEW went to a Emo-Pop/Pop Punkier route their music is still far richer than MCR's, Bleed American/Futures at their core are more ocmpelling record than anything MCR ever made
Thursday absolutely dominates MCR, I don't think there's a debate for that unless you really don't know what you're talking about or you value instant gratification over everything else. MCR is not capable of masterpieces like Autobiography of A Nation, they don't have Geoff Rickly's amazing lyricism.
This list just screams you want immediacy, not depth. Might sound pretentious, but the fact SDER/Thursday are at the bottom of your list is incredibly telling, it just screams musical illiteracy.

>>127119270
Amen

>>127119270
I think you're replying to at least 2 different people. It's nice that you enjoy Thursday so much. They need someone like you.

>>127119420
Doesn't matter if he did. You both share the same stupid opinions.

>>127119420
The only argument you can muster for MCR in this case is "they're more popular".
MCR indeed are more popular because Thursday refused to sell out after Full Collapse blew up, if Geoff deemed it so he could have made Mall Screamo after Full Collapse making music like MCR or Silverstein and literring his music with thousands of Pop-Punky hooky choruses, instead he doubled down into Post-Hardcore and made a far angrier louder record with War All The Time, focusing on artostoc integrity rather than the charts, because Thursday originate from the DYI Screamo/Emo scene, but that's something you clearly either don't understand nor refuse to appreciate.

>>127119270
Thursday is bare in melody, their songs, regardless of how "deep" the lyrics might be, aren't "original", much less catchy, MCR songs get me thinking "how did they find that chord progression ?!" Thursday'songs "meh, anyone could come up with that" they barely have any versatility, can't tell 2 songs apart. No, thursday is NOWHERE near MCR when it comes to writing, heck even Circa Survive beats Thursday's uninspired compositions at that.

>>127119457
You're proving my point that you just seek immediacy, hyperfocusing on melody/catchiness over all else in a music composition refusing to dig deeper.
I even disagree with the core argument as Thursday still managed to write great melodies with their compositions, MCR simply wrote Pop Punk hooks that are easier to digest, it's funny you think "wow HOW DID THEY FIND that chord progression?" Hilariously brain dead.
>can't tell 2 songs apart
If you confuse one song for another in Full Collapse you need to learn how to actually listen to music and pay attention to it, this opinion is born from someone who just puts music on the background while they check their emails or some shit. Thursday ironically are far more of a versatile band, Full Collapse alone is incredibly varied record and they only get more varied with each album to extends MCR never did.
I like Circa Survive a lot but they're not on level of Thursday to me still.

>>127119457
You're tripling down on being retarded. MCR gets you thinking? About what? Comic books and horror movies? That's all well and good but there's no real substance to what they do. Thursday have tons of catchy songs and, on top of it, they're interesting compositions. I like Circa Survive too but they're really not on par with what Thursday do.

>>127119485
A bunch of bullshit is what you wrote, I listened to the whole Thursday discography while lying down eyes closed, your guessing is as terrible as your music taste, the reason MCR got so successful, is because they're so MUCH better than Thursday, and people could see that. most of the time, with the exception of modern pop/rap, bands get the amount of success they deserve, the only underrated band on that list, apart from MCR itself, would be JEW, every other got their place in the emo/punk market.

>>127119547
Thursday would be fine as an audiobook, a pity they got in the wrong audio market.

>>127119566
This is what poptimism got us, retards like this. I don't know, maybe your brain is fractured if you can't Thursday songs apart, that's not Thursday's problems but yours, Thursday's songs were experimental avant-garde or anything but they weren't radio ready Pop-Punk infused, that's why they weren't as popular, you're merely excusing you liking more immediate artists over something that demands more attention. MCR got more attention because they were marketed more because their sound is clearly far more Pop infused and barely Post-Hardcore.

>>127119566
It's like arguing with a child. You're so fucking dense. There's no way this isn't bait.

>>127119592
Geoff talking would have more substance than any MCR album. This isn't the brag you think it is.

>>127119597
>Thursday's songs were "avant-garde" boring pretentious shit
Thanks for admitting, again I'd rather listen to Earthling, NIN, Pixies, or pretty much anything that has some rhythm.

>>127119664
You're admitting you can't handle anything that isn't pop punk verse chorus verse bullshit

>>127119664
Sorry, I meant to say "weren't" I meant to emphasize they in fact weren't comlpicated to understand. My point was the opposite.

>>127119246
see >>127119268 >>127119233
retard

>>127119600
Thursday is a shitty band, monotonous songs, boring melodies, pretentious lyrics, MCR mogs them so hard, one single of their songs has more talent than Thursday's whole discography.

>>127119457
based

>>127119677
And this changes what I said how? You're fucking retarded but not even on planet retard does anyone think TBS is better than Brand New.

>>127119600
>sOmEoNe DiSaGrEes WiTH mY reTarDeD oPinIoN i-It HaS tO bE BaIt!!!!!11111

>>127119683
The lyricism is pretentious if you are retarded so I can see why that's your critique, the songs don't always stick to verse-chorus so I can see why that'd be monotonous for you, on youtube you have tons of videos you can look up of people shaking keys around that seems something up to your tastes if you are looking for futher recomendations.
>>127119691
Your posts clearly expose you as a poptimist, it's just so blatant, the retardation is so strong we refuse to believe it's actually real and not an act.

>>127119683
>>127119684
Again, bait
>>127119691
You typed all of this with a black parade funkos lodged in your bussy

>>127119690
TBS literally has multiple songs/albums that are considered inarguable classics of the genre, including maybe the scene's most well known and classic emo songs ever, MakeDamnSure, Cute Without the E and You're So Last Summer. Brand New has meme albums that are spammed here by their autistic fans that in reality suck.

>>127119672
That's widely accepted to be the best way to compose a song. Thursday songs just don't have any "surprises" any catchy tunes to make them memorable, station to station is a 10:00 min song and is on my top 50 best, proving my taste isn't about being radio friendly/pop.

>>127119727
Lol, have you started listening to music this month?

>>127119735
Thursday shitty songs ?, no I listened to them last month.

>>127119754
I meant in general. If you think that Station To Station is something worthy of mentioning to showcase how eccletic your taste is, Bowie is literally the first artist people listen to seriously when they get into albums for real. Your lack of experience with music, especially with Post-Hardcore is very clear and you just prove more and more how little you know about the music you are trying to discuss. What other ballsy artists are in your top 50? Pink Floyd?

>>127119724
This shows what the other anon said. You can't handle anything that isn't basically pop music with guitars. It's why you favor MCR and TBS so much. And I like those first three TBS albums but there is a reason they fell off as hard as they did. They never tried to be anything more. Brand New and Thursday did and that's why they're remembered so fondly. They never made the same album twice or got comfortable. Same goes for Thursday.

>>127119724
BN first 3 albums are great, the 3rd is a bit long since it contains 2 big fillers, Daisy is OK, best enjoyed drunk/high, science fiction is a matter of taste, to me it tastes like crap.

>>127119727
What is Understanding In a Car Crash?

>>127119776
I mentioned Bowie because he was the first musician I really got into, and still on my top 5, Pink Floyd isn't even on my top 20, but high hopes is a great song. which artists should i mention then ? From First to last ?, A day to remember ? At the Drive through ? Emery?, last one would be the better out of the 4.

>>127110650 (OP)
someone post the real version

>>127119781
Brand New is boring as fuck. Thursday was influential but also wasn't as interesting or as talented songwriters as MCR, TBS, NFG, etc.

fuuuuuuuck no

>>127119965
Just admit you don't like Post-Hardcore and want Pop-Punk

>>127119965
https://youtu.be/vQro-SfANiY?si=G1h1qR6Cl6DLB6Dc , https://youtu.be/6FfF9fIDqFg?si=lFn250I6Fjqa5rO- The first album by Thursday was their best I'd give it an 8/10 War All The time was their 2nd best I'd give it a 7/10, the other ones a 6-6.5/10. As for brand new their 1st album was the best 8.5/10 their 2nd an 7/10 and their 3rd an 8/10.

>>127120054
I like both. Underoath is the GOAT post hardcore band

>>127119456
>because Thursday originate from the DYI Screamo/Emo scene, but that's something you clearly either don't understand nor refuse to appreciate.
Literally the same scene where mcr originates from.

>>127120054
Page Avenue is a good post hardcore album.
>>127119965
NFG is a less talented Blink 182.
>>127120148
True, theyre certainly better than Brand New.

>>127119456
>>127120259
Thursday literally conceded to MCR. You are absolutely blown the fuck out. Just stop lol

>>127119965
You're out of your fucking mind
>>127120054
This. You clearly have no interest in anything that isn't related to pop so fuck off trying to pretend otherwise
>>127120073
>Brand New's first album is their best
Yeah. You like pop punk. We've found where you belong
>>127120148
They're good but no
>>127120259
And? They owe their career to Geoff. Same goes for a lot of bands. You are aware Geoff is is connected to basically everything in that scene back then right? He was putting on shows for emo and post hardcore bands long before MCR was ever thought of
>>127120300
See above, dipshit

>>127119781
>They never made the same album twice
Neither did MCR, bullets sounds nothing like Revenge, which sounds nothing like TBP, which sounds nothing like DD.
Maybe I was a bit too harsh, on Thursday, they deserve a 7/10, maybe I overrated Brand New, as the other anon said, and they get a 7.5/10, but the fact is : There are many "Thursdays" (bands that sound similar) MCR is unique, not only on emo/punk-pop rock, but in music in general, being clearly different from shitty like panic!/FOB. Comparing MCR to these other bands,is like putting Jason Mamoa to compete in the special Olympics, then celebrate when he inevitably wins, just isnt fair, that's low.

>>127120580
Yeah. Every MCR album has gotten worse and tame. Same with TBS and they should have stopped while they were ahead and not become a laughing stock as soon as Fred left. MCR are an alright band. The problem with them is you sucking them off and praising them to high heaven like they're God's gift to music.

>>127120419
>>127120419
Thursday is the kind of band whose only claim to glory is as pioneers, and helping others climb to heights they themselves would never reach, for that I respect them.

>>127120419
Thursday is the kind of band whose only claim to glory is as pioneers helping others climb to heights they themselves would never reach, for that I respect them.

>>127120608
>worse
TBP is WIDELY considered the best MCR album https://loudwire.com/rock-bands-third-album-best/ 1) TBP 2) Revenge 3) Bullets/DD

>>127120663
For me it's:
1. Revenge
2. Bullets
3. TBP

>>127120627
It amazes me that someone who, obviously, has no clue what they're talking about feels the need to chime in and try to put down bands that actually did shit. Apart from not only putting your favorite band on the map, they have a flawless discography and left the entire genre changed in their wake. MCR sold marching band merchandise. I respect that. It can't be easy to get a gay marching band gimmick over.

>>127120054
Yes, I proudly don't.

>>127120800
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8-cepZ6K7mY
This song is just someone trying to sound like Morrissey singing over a complete rip off of At the Drive-In

>>127120916
It sounds nothing like Morrissey you dumb fuck. Nothing like At the Drive-In either. Are you sure your hearing is okay?

>>127120916
What part of it sounds like Morrisey, faggot? It's so obvious you have no idea what you're talking about, this song has deep connections to Midwest Emo, it even has twinkly guitars it's just few inches away from being Sunny Day Real Estate song. But you have on understanding of the musical language so you can only spout buzz-words and articulate yourself like a fucking child.
Notice how everyone againts you has far richer knowledge of these genres than you, you can only attack music you deem lesser with buzzwords as you lack both the intellect and knowledg about the subject you decided to discuss.
>>127120870
You probably don't even know what Post-Hardcore entails, only a faggot would proudly say they don't like bands like Fugazi, Unwound or Drive Like Jehu

>>127121093
>Fugazi, Unwound or Drive Like Jehu
lmao

>>127121105
Yeah, legendary bands, what's your point, faggot?

>>127121110
They're post-hardcore.

>>127121114
Well, yeah. If you dislike them and you prefer MCR over all of those bands then we might as well label all your posts as coming from Faggot Factory, of which you will be the CEO of.

>>127120941
>>127121093
The singer is trying to sound like Morrissey but he lacks the vocal ability to be consistent with anything. He is not a good vocalist.
You clearly know nothing about music from a musical perspective, you use terms like "twinkly guitars" and then cry about buzzwords because to you music is a fashion statement and a religious-political identity, you don't actually care for the music itself but for the social standing it sets you in.

>>127121093
MCR mogs all of those bands, you are such a faggot it's honestly astonishing. Be real, did you get bullied for liking MCR or something and now you're just forever insecure? What really happened man?

Kpop fan here, i prefer MCR

>>127121214
>The singer is trying to sound like Morrissey but he lacks the vocal ability to be consistent with anything. He is not a good vocalist.
No actually, Geoff is far more inspired by The Cure, and you can clearly hear this in Thursday's music as well.
As for Geoff's vocal abilities, it has greatly increased the more he performed with each record, but for most people this kind of stuff is part of the appeal in Emo, the rawness in the vocals.
>You clearly know nothing about music from a musical perspective
More than you, certainly. You don't even know what genre you're listening to.
>you use terms like "twinkly guitars" and then cry about buzzwords because to you music is a fashion statement and a religious-political identity
Who brought up religion or politics, faggot? It was never anywhere, we are simply telling you that you like Pop-Punk and get filtered by bands who have origins in Post-Hardcore.
>you don't actually care for the music itself but for the social standing it sets you in.
What gave you that idea? I know you're pathethically losing an argument, I am the one who consistently argues about music itself and how MCR objectively are far more hook based while Thursday's song-writting doesn't always follow verse-chorus structure.
>>127121238
Go back to work Mr.Faggot.

>>127121255
You've done well to shoehorn your band into this thread, Geoff.

>>127121328
You really are incapable of discussing nuances of music on any level or any capacity, you did try but all you could muster was arguing againts arguments no one made.

>>127112351
I will only concede that the last track with ben stiller acting like a faggot isn't strong.

Funny how MCR threads are popping up as soons as they are on their stadium tours. Really make you wonder

>>127121145
Very childish response. But I suppose that's par the course when it comes to pop-punk/post-hardcore fans.

>>127121395
No one cares about this place anymore, I don't think that's what it is, this is the most dead place for discussion of music on the internet.

>>127121255
>No actually, Geoff is far more inspired by The Cure,
Yuck, don't disrespect the Cure by mentioning them in the same sentence as bland post-hardcore crap.

>>127121406
Nice try to feign maturity, but in doing so you implied that the bands listed were somehow related to Pop Punk in anyway so you accidentally exposed yourself as someone who really has no idea what he's talking about.

Well, at the end of the day I'm glad everyone agree MCR mogs the shit out of Thursday, and that the greatest, most noble thing Thursday ever did, was helping the world find out about this gem.

I need to chime in to say that while Thursday has made some cool records, it is absurd to say that they didn't sell out. The change from War all the Time to whatever the gay ass record was after that was jarring. I remember reading an interview where dude says that their old records didn't make sense musically because the guys didn't understand chord progressions and so they just would scream to make the songs sound more intense.

>>127121409
What are the biggest places to discuss music other than rym ?

>>127121448
That album was very eccletic and transitional, though I don't see what parts of it is "sell out" there's only one song that got on the radio, but they also had a single from that album that sounded like this.
https://youtu.be/P3IagEQI75U?si=7QCzKKbDCnUdQtLT
Only Counting 5-4-3-2-1 was really radio ready in any capacity.
Rest of the album goes all over the place but none of it really sounds like selling out to me. It sounds like natural progression of War All The Time where they were implementing more Post-Rock/Alt.Rock influences, City By The Light Divided just goes even more into them while still retaining Post-Hardcore.

>>127121515
Damn why is Geoff so fucked up looking?
Also doesn't he have TDS?
Sad!

>>127121214
Find me a Morrissey song that sounds anything like a Thursday song. You seriously need to get your ears checked. You can't distinguish between songs. You think Moz and Geoff are at all similar. The shit you say is baffling.
>>127121328
You've done well at not answering a single thing anyone has said coherently
>>127121415
Fuck you, faggot. The Cure have maybe one album worth a shit.
>>127121419
Nope. And Gerard isn't ever gonna fuck you either regardless of how much you overrate and overhype his albums
>>127121572
Turn you monitor on, dumbass

>>127121418
I know those bands aren't pop-punk. You're the one that brought it up earlier >>127120054

>>127121880
>Fuck you, faggot. The Cure have maybe one album worth a shit.
lmao you're literally a fan of post-hardcore. what do you know about quality? shut the fuck up.

>>127121880
Goeff looks bad, homo.
Also that song is mid as fuck.
The band peaked with War All The Time and they were always trying to chase popularity, but just didn't have the know how.

>>127121971
I know that there's nothing good about 70 year old man dressing like a clown, writing 7th grade level 'bad, sad' rhyming techniques and making the same album one hundred times.
>>127122006
You know jack shit. A major approached them and tried to make them into emo Nirvana. Something they never wanted and who could blame them? And why do you care what Geoff looks like? What does that have to do with musical ability? It's almost like you want Gerard to fuck you and you will overlook the corny pop punk garbage they pump out

>>127122089
I don't even like MCR you malding faggot.
Didn't Thursday release albums on Island?
That is a major label you assclown.
Maybe they didn't like producers trying to tell them how to make their songs better, but to imply that they weren't trying for popularity is asinine.

>>127122139
Sure you aren't. And who claimed they didn't? They signed with Island and it was nothing but hurdles for them. LA Reid wanted them to be emo Nirvana like i said. They can write hooks as well as anyone but that's not where their hearts are. They handled the major label signing as well as Jimmy Eat World and made two interesting albums that should have performed better. I don't know what your point is.

>>127122232
The albums sucked and that is why they didn't perform.
You are gay and deluded.

>>127122287
You're deaf and retarded and that's why you're simping so hard for MCR

but that's not Revolutions Per Minute

For me I love the hits (Helena, Thank You for the Venom, Ghost of You) and the rest is just meh. Which probably means I don't get it. The Foo Fighters are the same for me. I love Everlong, but the whole album is just..bleh

>>127122663
Foo Fighters mog mcr lol
It’s not even close

>>127110650 (OP)
/mu/ will be all high and mighty against pop music and then their biggest threads are nostalgic revisionism of shitty YA fiction music

>>127122714
I've never seen /mu/ dedicate its biggest threads to Coheed and Cambria though who fit that description so much better (except Coheed is really good trust me)

>>127110650 (OP)
post the best most edge kino songs from that album right now.

>>127122730
Shut the fuck up

>>127122746
See >>127122754

>>127122754
No

>>127122802
>>127122754

>>127122813
OK, you win..*kneels solemnly*

jfc what a sad little faggot

>>127122915
>>127122754

>>127122686
Poo fighters are nothing next to MCR, they don't have 1/3 of the talent/innovation that went into any MCR album.
"No one is a prophet in their own land" Were MCR a 1970s band, they'd be praised as highly as the Beatles, but given most people here are old enough to remember when their songs became popular, they feel the need to put it down (also due to a lot of anons here liking the garbage called rap, and current pop shit like Olivia) In due time, Revenge will be seen as another "Revolver".

>>127123177
>>127122754

>>127122416
I already said MCR sucks but your delusional worship of Thursday needed to be addressed

>>127123177
>Were MCR a 1970s band, they'd be praised as highly as the Beatles, but given most people here are old enough to remember when their songs became popular, they feel the need to put it down
Based and checked

>>127123366
>>127123363
See >>127122754

>>127123374
CD’s nuts faggot

>>127123389
>>127122754

>>127123374
Eat shit ! also >>127122754 MCR rules !

>>127123399
What a lazy way to post.
You can’t even be bothered to type out your homosexual ramblings anymore.
Were you even listening to music when the records being discussed were released?

>>127123437
>>127123438
See >>127122754
>>127122765
>>127122813
>>127123174
>>127123191
>>127123374
>>127123399

>>127123521
So… underage?

>>127123809
>>127122754

that's alotta slop

>>127110650 (OP)
helana alone solos

Whoa, hey, I found a better album!

>>127125822
This album is a 7.5, Revenge is a 9.5

>>127120419
>And?
Because you were bragging about the fact that they come from the NJ post-hardcore scene while shitting on MCR, when it is the very same scene MCR comes from and you were praising Thursday's artistic integrity while putting down MCR when Thursday considers MCR their scene comrades, are proud of their success and are praising their artistry. If MCR is slop then Thursday are huge sellouts because they keep praising them to the heavens and keep working with them. Their drummer, Tucker Rule is literally on tour with MCR right now and shares a band with Frank Iero.
>He was putting on shows for emo and post hardcore bands long before MCR was ever thought of
Nothing about the post you replied to implied that mcr came first, just pointing out their shared origins, connection and mutual respect for each other. Give it up, Thursday themselves don't agree with you. Same goes for the MCRfag who shits on Thursday.

>>127125822
what even is this