Order of metal scenes/subscenes by significance/prevalence per subgenre - /mu/ (#127125679) [Archived: 910 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/22/2025, 6:15:14 AM No.127125679
thinking pepe
thinking pepe
md5: 7de5b1c674a71b852ee4d8db7428bd3b🔍
Heavy: UK, USA, Germany, Argentina, Japan
Thrash: USA (San Francisco + NYC), Germany, Canada, Brazil, Chile
Death: USA (Florida + NYC), Sweden (Stockholm + Gothenburg), Finland, UK, Canada, Netherlands, Poland, Indonesia
Black: Norway, Sweden, Finland, France, USA (Pacific Northwest), Greece, Ukraine/Eastern Europe, Canada (Quebec)
Doom: USA (DC + Louisiana + Southwest), UK, Finland, Sweden, Norway, Italy
Power: Germany, Sweden, Japan, Finland, USA, Italy, Spain
Metalcore: USA (Massachusetts + Ohio + California), UK, Australia, Germany
Progressive: USA, Sweden, Canada Symphonic: Finland, Netherlands, Germany, Japan, Italy
Folk: Finland, Germany, Eastern Europe, Scandinavia/Iceland, Ireland

Do you overall agree or disagree? What countries can I add, omit, or rearrange?
Replies: >>127126224 >>127128743
Anonymous
7/22/2025, 6:17:40 AM No.127125704
better readability:
>Heavy
UK, USA, Germany, Argentina, Japan
>Thrash
USA (San Francisco + NYC), Germany, Canada, Brazil, Chile (also adding Australia here)
>Death
USA (Florida + NYC), Sweden (Stockholm + Gothenburg), Finland, UK, Canada, Netherlands, Poland, Indonesia
>Black
Norway, Sweden, Finland, France, USA (Pacific Northwest), Greece, Ukraine/Eastern Europe, Canada (Quebec)
>Doom
USA (DC + Louisiana + Southwest), UK, Finland, Sweden, Norway, Italy
>Power
Germany, Sweden, Japan, Finland, USA, Italy, Spain
>Metalcore
USA (Massachusetts + Ohio + California), UK, Australia, Germany
>Progressive
USA, Sweden, Canada Symphonic: Finland, Netherlands, Germany, Japan, Italy
>Folk
Finland, Germany, Eastern Europe, Scandinavia/Iceland, Ireland
Replies: >>127128743
Anonymous
7/22/2025, 7:48:41 AM No.127126224
>>127125679 (OP)
seems about right. add melodeath
Replies: >>127128610
Anonymous
7/22/2025, 3:50:25 PM No.127128610
>>127126224
sweden, finland, usa, uk

still looking through melodeath scenes, but this is what i got so far
Anonymous
7/22/2025, 4:12:53 PM No.127128743
>>127125679 (OP)
>>127125704
I think you should just go by bands, records, etc. At least first and foremost. Everyone of those needs to have a song etc.