>>127129350 (OP)
Billy wrote his own shit and isn't an AIDS-ridden faggot. Elton isnt a jew. Tough call, but I say Billy.

>>127129350 (OP)
whom

>>127129457
check out the JDS on this guy
Billy treats his bands like shit.
Everyone who's worked with Elton loves him.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BabX8k1myTc

>>127129583
Checks out. I watched the BJ documentary, and apparently when he was starting out his bandmate gave him a place to stay since he was broke, and BJ cucked him with his wife.

>>127129350 (OP)
I like billy's music more, I guess. But he's a really a Paul-a-like at the end of the day. So I like Paul.

My mom casually told me the other day that even though she thinks Billy is a better musician, she prefers Elton because he's less ugly. I got legitimately mad but I do kind of agree.

>>127129350 (OP)
They actually have similiar aura and accomplishments so they balance each other out

>>127129350 (OP)
Joel is better

>>127129350 (OP)
Elton mogs all day and night. Twice the creativity. Billy could have never made Tumbleweed Connection or Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.

I feel like this is a really odd pair to put up against each other. For me Billy Joel consistently had more songs that I enjoy but their music style is pretty different.

>>127129350 (OP)
i remember listening to an interview of billy joel's former drummer. he'd give billy shit all the time and add new lyrics to his song to trigger him about his ex-wife such as..
> SHE TOOK THE HOUSE, SHE TOOK THE CAR

>>127129350 (OP)
right guy made more catchy songs

>>127129350 (OP)
Billy himself said Elton is superior.

>>127129350 (OP)
They're not really similar at all. But Elton is way better. Tumbleweed Connection alone is better than Billy's entire discography.

I can't even tell them apart musically.