Who mogs whom?

With Paul at the helm The Beatles were ascending
With Peter Gabriel out and Phil Collins at the helm Genesis sank

as a songwriter : Paul easily wins
as a decent human being : Phil by a massive margin

>>127250188
>decent human being
Holy reddit

>>127250188
>decent human being
Holy based

>>127250141 (OP)
Phil is (or was I should say) way better at his instrument.

>>127250141 (OP)
the first quote sounds like phil being unable to handle bants, but the second one makes more sense. when you spend your entire adult life having the ground you walk on worshipped, there's no way it's not going to your head and you see yourself as above all the other plebs

>>127250141 (OP)
He was rejcted? Phil played drums on a track in "All things must pass", when he was like 18 or 19

Brown "people" post on this board and are itt. Disgusting. Like Phil Collins.

Linda Perry of "4 non blondes" and prolific songwriter had written songs for Ringo. She has told her story about meeting Paul and she too introduced herself and immediately asked for an autograph. He shot her down on the spot and later appologised about it.
She said that paul reacts that way to autograph requests from other celebrities and working professionals because to him it ruins all social interactions hes been in for the past 60 years. The moment he pulls a pen out it changes the mood of the room, causes a chain reaction of other people wanting things signed and making other people uncomfortable, the ones who felt it was inappropriate to ask at the time. He comes across as a dick but it shuts down the feeding frenzy before it begins. That isnt ego it is a genuine problem for any of the mega celebrities. Paul has probably been asked for more autographs than any living human, rivaled only by the likes of muhamed ali and michael jackson. She said that Paul instead prefers giving little gifts and mementos to collaborators or people he meets, preferable in private away from the big gala events or studios where people are working.

Other times paul will be out on a bike ride, meet a group of fans randomly at the edge of some lake and happily sign autographs and do the selfie thing. As long as it isnt in a restaurant or airport he can be very generous with his time. This is true for many celebrities.
Tl:dr
It was the wrong place and time for Phil to ask for a book signing. He should have known better.

>>127250141 (OP)
this sounds very petty of phil but maybe he was just joking

>as a decent human being

>>127250631
hate this talentless whore

Phil is a right bloke
Paul is [spoiler]dead[/spoiler]

>>127250793
>How beer became white.
According to the ancient Greeks and Romans, beer was popular among the Egyptians, the Thracians and the Germanics. Even if we use nigger science and claim Egyptians were black beer was still pretty white.

>>127250631
lol… it’s over… you cannot salvage Paul’s image. We all know he’s a little goblin. Here’s the best Paul story
>not too many years ago
>he decides to go to a rapper’s party
>bouncer at the club says invite only
>paul goes on about well I guess the Beatles aren’t big enough!
>bouncer says “cool bro you aint on the list”
Would have given anything to be there.

>>127251033
the funny thing is that he would even bother to go to the party of a rapper he clearly does not know. i guess his ego was just that large that he thought anyone would yield to him

>gossip between 2 shitty musicians
I feel bad for you, anon

>>127250931
>there are only black people and white people

>>127250931
>Even if we use nigger science and claim Egyptians were black
We all know the ancient Egyptians were wide blonde haired Germanics

>>127251033
>In 2016, Paul McCartney, along with Beck and Taylor Hawkins, was denied entry to Tyga's Grammys after-party at The Argyle nightclub in Hollywood. A bouncer reportedly stopped them at the door. McCartney joked, "How VIP do we gotta get? We need another hit," according to The Guardian and Vogue. Tyga later stated he wasn't aware McCartney was there and didn't control the door.
>>127251430
It was the grammy afterparty. The dindu security guard had no idea who any of the white people were and turned them all away. Paul thought it was hillarious.

>>127250157
Huh? Genesis literally became famous under Phil Collins, to this day normalfags mostly associate the band with him.

>>127253486
I'm genx MTV generation and I have no idea what Peter Gabriel era Genesis sounds like.

>>127250371
>>127250371
>>127250340
>>127250854
>>127251033

Paul McCartney is well known to be a complete cunt so it's unsurprising that he was like this to Phil Collins.
McCartney refuses to allow anyone working on his concerts (stage crew, people working at the venue, anyone on site) to eat anything except vegan food, as well as requesting that all the furniture be 'vegan friendly'.

Phil in every way

>>127253864
I don't either. I can't imagine I'm missing much. Gabriel is a one album wonder anyway.

>>127250631
The worst Phil Collins song mogs anything Paul has ever done.

Paul and Phil are both fantastic musicians. Watching Paul work during the Let It Be miniseries was amazing. He could come up with wonderful pop songs so quickly out of nowhere. The Beatles have a ton of good stuff from their boy band pop stuff to their more psychedelic later stuff and Paul is (I imagine) largely behind the best of the music.

Genesis up until and including Duke was fantastic. Sure there were some slips, but they were still making incredible art. And Phil even made some good pop music. The Tarzan soundtrack is chock full of it.

I don't know the rest of the interaction between the two of them. I don't know Paul's sense of humor. I don't even know if Phil is taking the piss there. I don't care about them as people. I just like their music.

>>127250141 (OP)
>Phil Collins vs _______
>Who mogs whom
You would have to start digging below the tier of Red Hot Chili Peppers before you find famous musicians who Phil Collins mogs.

>>127250141 (OP)
that's really ironic because paul's entire discography is him interpolating other music that made him feel inferior

>>127253864
>>127254288
If you enjoy stuff like Yes and King Crimson, you'll probably like Peter Gabriel and even the early Phil Collins era of Genesis.

>>127254832
he came up with a lot of stuff because he just took inspirations from other things his listened to. strawberry fields forever and octopus garden are probably their only two original ideas

>>127250141 (OP)
I can't wait for Paul to fuck off and die already

>>127250141 (OP)
>>127250157
>>127250188
Paul and Phil are 2/3 musicians who have sold over 100M records both in a band and as a solo artist.

>>127254832
What are the best post-Gabriel/Phil era Genesis albums?

>>127254943
Do you know how creativity works? Nobody comes up with something out of nothing. Everybody is inspired by something.

>>127255049
If you like Gabriel Genesis, then Trick Of The Tail and Wind And Wuthering are good (Steve Hackett was still with the band). You can see the cracks in W&W (Your Own Special Way is rough), but I maintain the final three tracks on that album mog pretty much everything from Gabriel Genesis.

I also think Duke is worth having in your library. It's poppy, but there's a lot of great pop and prog pop on there.

>>127254972
This

>>127255049
The run from A Trick of the Tail to Duke is pretty good, the remaining albums aren't quite as good but Abacab and Genesis are solid pop albums, and even weaker ones Invisible Touch and We Can't Dance have a handful of great tracks here and there.

>>127250631
Phil also makes this sound like the first time he and Paul had met, but they'd known each other for decades. They'd done a photoshoot and worked in the studio together in the 80s. It kinda warrants a little mocking when you autograph hunt from someone who is essentially a peer and a friend, or maybe Paul thought they were friendly enough it would be taken as a joke.

Phil brings it up when he wants to promote himself anyway, that alone is proof of who mogs whom. When would Paul ever bring Phil up for headlines? Paul also has a full head of hair over 80.

>>127255345
Yeah, Invisible Touch and We Can't Dance are pretty uneven albums, but Domino, No Son of Mine and Jesus He Knows Me are bangers

>>127250141 (OP)
damn Phil Collins sounds like a bitch

>>127250141 (OP)
Wait, let me see if I understood that. Phil was mad because he was called a manlet by Paul?

>>127254018
just sounds like someone who holds strong beliefs

>>127250141 (OP)
McCartney never made Undertale

>>127255440
Based

>>127250854
Our little Anon's a bit of a Phil fan.