>>509106877He is, it's just the facts
>>509105247 (OP)She had it rough, it is her, the nose and the lips are the same, there's the scars too, she just has a different gaze but the eyes are there, photographer just put her in different light than in the first one.
When she was a kid she had a bright light source in the left with something away rebounding in the center right, hence the shadows, in the grown up pic she has a general diffuse light in the center hence almost no shadows; you can see that in the eyes and the nose tip.