Were Confederates sufficiently punished? - /pol/ (#509434652) [Archived: 678 hours ago]

Anonymous ID: Z3RwsWNdSweden
7/3/2025, 11:53:01 PM No.509434652
1237891236789123
1237891236789123
md5: 0005ce3faa9625320b5124f401a88c29🔍
Replies: >>509435876 >>509436204 >>509436533 >>509436615 >>509436654 >>509436689 >>509436763 >>509437432 >>509437470 >>509437722 >>509438007 >>509438732 >>509438996 >>509439295 >>509439335 >>509439354 >>509441638 >>509441674 >>509441754 >>509442038 >>509442329 >>509442363 >>509442409 >>509442557 >>509443211 >>509443305 >>509444064 >>509444586 >>509444705 >>509444711 >>509445477 >>509448182
Anonymous ID: tl1aeXZICanada
7/4/2025, 12:05:37 AM No.509435696
INB4 "MUH PARTIES SWITCHED"
Replies: >>509444851 >>509448182
Anonymous ID: Ov9e/1/+United States
7/4/2025, 12:06:35 AM No.509435782
1744823060677334
1744823060677334
md5: 5b273e52d3a1d9be4c0ca82db4eefcce🔍
no
Replies: >>509436533 >>509437650 >>509445536
Anonymous ID: 2MYejCKuUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:07:47 AM No.509435876
1677757581880142
1677757581880142
md5: 6209253ba34143ba33b45e2fae38e551🔍
>>509434652 (OP)
>taking anything a sheboon says seriously
Anonymous ID: eOGuzsD6United States
7/4/2025, 12:09:20 AM No.509436004
photo_2025-06-30_07-00-36
photo_2025-06-30_07-00-36
md5: 4ef6008d78e0da3b96c7b70fcbfdeb23🔍
come and say it to my face UniOnFaG
Replies: >>509438156
Anonymous ID: RDP1+k9vUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:11:42 AM No.509436204
>>509434652 (OP)
Davis should have been hanged for treason at the very least
Replies: >>509436952 >>509437184
Anonymous ID: 1VW3uo6lUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:15:55 AM No.509436533
>>509434652 (OP)
Quick point on that, actually the South surrendered. There were terms of surrender, and one of the terms was southern soldiers kept their sidearms (generally a revolver).

>>509435782
:^) Sherman married his sister, and has no surviving heirs. God judged him, and he is not seen anymore - where can you find him? Gone like the wind.
Anonymous ID: InwDKKLuUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:17:02 AM No.509436615
>>509434652 (OP)
>>509429994
tells all
Anonymous ID: zEGBRmmJUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:17:29 AM No.509436654
rebelflag
rebelflag
md5: ae4946c2ab759a6b94c4e3221de1001b🔍
>>509434652 (OP)
The South will rise again
t. Californian
rebels are cool
Replies: >>509438398
Anonymous ID: 8q4rtQL/Lithuania
7/4/2025, 12:18:03 AM No.509436689
>>509434652 (OP)
yeah you should have punished them by deporting all their precious blacks back to africa. That would show em
Replies: >>509437737
Anonymous ID: wpxsT0hlCanada
7/4/2025, 12:18:57 AM No.509436763
>>509434652 (OP)
>Dr.
I bet
Anonymous ID: 1VW3uo6lUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:21:19 AM No.509436952
>>509436204
Why's that? The present union is the unlawful one. By my very nature my soul is the more holy, being not in the iniquity of the usurpers against the law.
Replies: >>509437359 >>509437893
Anonymous ID: sjWqB6XwUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:24:19 AM No.509437184
>>509436204
He will come to you
Replies: >>509441127
Anonymous ID: Z3RwsWNdSweden
7/4/2025, 12:26:20 AM No.509437359
>>509436952
Why are you defending the leftists?
Replies: >>509439360
Anonymous ID: XF+QAEPmUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:27:19 AM No.509437432
>>509434652 (OP)
there shouldn't be a single nigger in this country
Anonymous ID: g0cRWxPcUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:27:45 AM No.509437470
>>509434652 (OP)
This is happening because browns are awful
Anonymous ID: qLwY0JakUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:30:02 AM No.509437650
>>509435782
Sherman hated niggers. He couldn't even be in the same room with niggers without sperging out. Also be is a top 10 injun remover. I honestly think he had autism.
Anonymous ID: IxJJbfs5United States
7/4/2025, 12:31:00 AM No.509437722
>>509434652 (OP)
Every single traitorous slaver should've been hanged.
Anonymous ID: amXAbW6JUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:31:06 AM No.509437737
>>509436689
They tried, that's how Liberia was created.
Replies: >>509439488
Anonymous ID: qLwY0JakUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:31:40 AM No.509437787
The only sin of the Confederacy is bringing niggers here in the first place. They should have picked their own cotton.
Replies: >>509439480
Anonymous ID: BtROWj8zUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:32:19 AM No.509437834
There is no constitutional arguement against secession.
Anonymous ID: RDP1+k9vUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:32:54 AM No.509437893
>>509436952
>Why's that?
Because 700,000 American men died as a direct result of his hubris.
>The present union is the unlawful one. By my very nature my soul is the more holy
By your own delusional standards, you are a moral coward standing idly by under the reign of an unlawful government.
You do not get to claim the mantel of your glorious forefathers while cowering in the shadows.
Anonymous ID: s6AnsFgLUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:33:41 AM No.509437951
521342
521342
md5: 6dff73ec59643f06c8908bb678e5c6f3🔍
>economy reduced to ashes and it doesn't recover until 1920
>immediately enter the great depression
>parts of the south are like "what the fuck is electricity"
>sort of recover by the 1960's
>anniversary of the civil war
>hit them with civil rights
>were they punished enough
Replies: >>509438122
Anonymous ID: qLwY0JakUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:33:42 AM No.509437952
Slavery ended because of technology. It simply became uneconomic to have a bunch of low IQ breeders pick cotton when a tractor/gin could do it 10 times faster and 10 times cheaper. Niggers are outdated farm equipment.
Anonymous ID: CxKpWC0cUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:34:32 AM No.509438007
>>509434652 (OP)
No it happening because Lincoln got assassinated and never had a change to implement back to Africa plan
Replies: >>509438137
Anonymous ID: qLwY0JakUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:36:00 AM No.509438122
>>509437951
Southerners got the north back by giving a bunch of niggers one way train tickets to NYC and Chicago. I love how niggers act like they have always been in NYC when they only started showing up (unwanted) in the 1920s.
Replies: >>509438205
Anonymous ID: fyONKuZMAustralia
7/4/2025, 12:36:10 AM No.509438137
>>509438007
He was never sending them back
Anonymous ID: dU0uTtpLUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:36:28 AM No.509438156
>>509436004
This pic man.
I know a guy who is doing all the things he says should be making him happy.
>On HRT bullshit poison
>Dosing and triple dosing antidepressants
>Weed dude
>Video gayms
>Spent money on a concert ticket
>Scrolling on social media and getting multiple affirmations and confirmations of their gender and political stances
>Pays for therapy
And they still aren't happy.
Not a bit and they are confused as to why none of it is working but finds anything else as silly.
Is there any hope for these people? Like even just a tiny shred of hope they can look forward to?
Anonymous ID: s6AnsFgLUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:37:07 AM No.509438205
>>509438122
southerners were very against the niggers leaving because only the lazy ones were left in the south
Replies: >>509438864 >>509439073 >>509441558
Anonymous ID: PJegb8tmUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:39:40 AM No.509438398
>>509436654
The view of the confederate flag has really changed over the last 15 years. You used to be able to wear shirts or bandanas without being harassed, now everyone gets all pissy
Anonymous ID: dttDinktUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:44:17 AM No.509438732
>>509434652 (OP)
The union insisted on being needlessly punitive, only to simply give up on reconstruction. They basically forced the confederate states to have black legislators who were previously slaves. Regardless of race, someone who's spent their whole life picking cotton isn't going to know much about being a legislator; it shouldn't surprise anyone that those blacks did a terrible job and were absurdly corrupt. Instead of achieving equality, all it did was reinforce stereotypes about blacks being too stupid to govern.
Replies: >>509438880 >>509439193
Anonymous ID: qLwY0JakUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:46:10 AM No.509438864
>>509438205
I have lived in both NYC and North Carolina and niggers are definitely way more stupid, lazy, and violent in NYC than in North Carolina. I think it's because many of them are military niggers down there on top of everything being more spread out. The worst niggers in the world are Memphis/St. Louis niggers, followed by Oakland niggers.
Replies: >>509443754
Anonymous ID: s6AnsFgLUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:46:16 AM No.509438880
>>509438732
they didn't give up, they installed puppet governments where they controlled everything and the KKK went around spooking their hired negroes while they embezzled tax revenue (taxes which were raised to extortionate levels after having your state's economy destroyed) all while being unable to vote

they were pushed out
Replies: >>509439689
Anonymous ID: 8ZAk5DMxUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:47:26 AM No.509438996
>>509434652 (OP)
Yes, we never should have bought the slaves the northerners brought over, and we never should have let slaves voluntarily move to Texas after the war since slavery was still legal there.
Replies: >>509439243
Anonymous ID: H3xoxwyGUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:48:22 AM No.509439073
>>509438205
Southerns, Confederacy, dub Gubberment! blah, blah, blah...

They were all jew niggers.
Every single fucking one of them!
NON-CHRISTIAN, Gentile, Canaanite, Juden niggers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judah_P._Benjamin
The nigger jew died in France.
Replies: >>509439214
Anonymous ID: RDP1+k9vUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:50:03 AM No.509439193
3stzy.oq1b.2-small-The-Apprentice-US-Season-3-
3stzy.oq1b.2-small-The-Apprentice-US-Season-3-
md5: 1af663d8dce771d8b1089ed5ac6dc1bf🔍
>>509438732
>Regardless of race, someone who's spent their whole life picking cotton isn't going to know much about being a legislator; it shouldn't surprise anyone that those blacks did a terrible job and were absurdly corrupt.
Relevant experience is necessary for effective governance, you say?
Replies: >>509439689 >>509448356
Anonymous ID: s6AnsFgLUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:50:18 AM No.509439214
>>509439073
Shut up retard
Replies: >>509439292
Anonymous ID: H3xoxwyGUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:50:42 AM No.509439243
>>509438996
>Yes, we never should have bought the slaves the (nigger jews) brought over.

nigger jews like Kamala & nigger jews like Obama
Anonymous ID: H3xoxwyGUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:51:19 AM No.509439292
>>509439214
fuck your mother nigger!
Anonymous ID: VmBwrGwVUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:51:20 AM No.509439295
>>509434652 (OP)
Read up on the history of reconstruction and how it was resisted and fumbled, and the rise of jim crow and you'll find the answer is a resounding no. Race relations in America today would be way better if there was any effort put in.
Anonymous ID: 4dCAIj+mUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:51:49 AM No.509439335
>>509434652 (OP)
The premise of this question is kind of misleading in that it implies that punishing the confederates more would have somehow made your average southern Joe view the confederacy less favorably. As a matter of fact there’s an argument to be made that the opposite is true, that the average southerner would be more resentful if every confederate rebel had been hung/put in prison for life after the end of the civil war, or actions had been taken solely to make life harder for southerners to punish them for the civil war. The north was looking to re-unite with the southern states after all rather than rule over them which required tensions be addressed with a level of care rather than brute force.

That being said, there are definitely areas in which the north could have done much better in post-civil war reconstruction. Many Africans who were freed found themselves without possessions after the civil war and the U.S.’s failure to provide them with means by which to properly integrate into southern society would lead to the Jim Crow era, manifesting racial tensions which continue to echo into modern politics. While American laws and views towards freedom of speech make this sort of thing more difficult to control, the north definitely could have played a stronger role in regulating the education of children post-war on the importance of the civil war and defeat of the confederacy to America, rather than allowing “lost cause” and “war of northern aggression” narratives to be circulated by more resentful southerners.

Honestly I dunno how much of a difference that would make with relation to modern politics, though. Even if post-war reconstruction had gone better you’d still inevitably have resentful, prejudiced portions of the population who would vote accordingly given how democracy needs to empower everyone to vote to work.
Anonymous ID: zL+5JYs+United Kingdom
7/4/2025, 12:52:02 AM No.509439354
>>509434652 (OP)
Sounds like that nigger hasn't been whipped hard enough.
Replies: >>509439435
Anonymous ID: 1VW3uo6lUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:52:04 AM No.509439360
>>509437359
>leftists
I'll defend the right of jews to burn the talmud. They have every right!
Anonymous ID: 1VW3uo6lUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:52:52 AM No.509439435
>>509439354
There are many indications that whipping niggers doesn't stop them from raping and strangling niggresses.
Anonymous ID: GKy4iIbT
7/4/2025, 12:53:33 AM No.509439480
>>509437787
It was Yankees who shipped them here.

Ol’ Glory flew on many slavers.
Anonymous ID: rNspQ4CiUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:53:40 AM No.509439488
>>509437737
the union's official position in the war was supposed to deport them from the country. living in servitude was the only position of them even staying in the nation at the time.
Anonymous ID: dttDinktUnited States
7/4/2025, 12:56:41 AM No.509439689
>>509438880
>they were pushed out
The union could've tried to use military strength to force the issue, but the political will wasn't there.
>>509439193
>but what about Trump
can you stupid niggers ever discuss a single thing in the world without bringing up Trump or Harry Potter?
Anonymous ID: As/2v5YdUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:15:27 AM No.509441127
>>509437184
Underrated
Anonymous ID: HTI4CU+GUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:20:39 AM No.509441558
>>509438205
This part is often overlooked in history. As much as Southerners hated black people, they still needed them for the economy
Anonymous ID: tLlW590KUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:21:45 AM No.509441638
>>509434652 (OP)
why do niggers make "slavery" and "being black" their whole fucking personality?
Anonymous ID: U/xkLL2VUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:22:22 AM No.509441674
>>509434652 (OP)
What do they mean by this? What punishment do they have in mind?
Anonymous ID: vqHMnnXP
7/4/2025, 1:23:37 AM No.509441754
>>509434652 (OP)
They need to pay reparashuns
Anonymous ID: QQQFaz/nUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:27:32 AM No.509442038
>>509434652 (OP)
Yes.

If the Confederates hadn't been pardoned and welcomed back into the Union, they wouldn't have surrendered, and the Civil War would have devolved into a protracted insurgency that would have gradually exhausted the economy and manpower of the nation. Instead of winning the Spanish-American War and becoming a major world power, we'd have languished as a failed state, and probably played host to a proxy war between England and Germany around the time of WWI.
Anonymous ID: rkA8cc24United States
7/4/2025, 1:31:12 AM No.509442329
>>509434652 (OP)
She certainly looks like a doctor. Neuroscience?
Anonymous ID: gTn9r+CHUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:31:32 AM No.509442357
Kings-with-Janice-Rothchild-Blumberg
Kings-with-Janice-Rothchild-Blumberg
md5: 7c64301e256efcb2eb6cd7f73d2c2b54🔍
>niggers demand something
>yankees immediately do everything in their power to gibs dem dat

why tho?
Anonymous ID: QwGaVjIDUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:31:38 AM No.509442363
>>509434652 (OP)
they should've been exterminated for being too lazy to pick their own goddamn cotton
Anonymous ID: g0K6iXj0United States
7/4/2025, 1:32:12 AM No.509442409
>>509434652 (OP)
>Were Confederates sufficiently punished?
We still have democrats... So I guess the answer is no.
Anonymous ID: eQBvuArsUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:34:04 AM No.509442557
>>509434652 (OP)
Yankees are the biggest pussies on earth and it shows since they’re basically all but gone by now.
Anonymous ID: ofp37FydIreland
7/4/2025, 1:36:29 AM No.509442753
What a stupid fucking nigger
Anonymous ID: 840fgT2WUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:36:57 AM No.509442787
democrats were the confederates, and the pro slave party and many of them owned slaves and they pass the jim crow laws and started the kkk

they like to pretend that was all republicans when in fact the republican party was form to help put an end to slavery do to many of the abolitionist being part of the founding of the republicans.
Anonymous ID: ZaduHJFPUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:42:06 AM No.509443211
>>509434652 (OP)
They won. America is flooded with .ore niggers and spics and honest abe was shot in the face while lee lived
Anonymous ID: DU/snx7rUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:43:20 AM No.509443305
>>509434652 (OP)

Niggers need to be dumped into the ocean
Anonymous ID: ZaduHJFPUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:49:27 AM No.509443754
>>509438864
Nc niggers are like 30 to 50% white. Nyc niggers are in the 85% and up group
T.my family is full of little half niggers
Anonymous ID: 2sVGLYkDUnited States
7/4/2025, 1:54:05 AM No.509444064
>>509434652 (OP)
Yeah
all the blacks should have been deported back to Africa or given some island for their own
r
Replies: >>509445334
Anonymous ID: Y9beX1YlUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:01:08 AM No.509444586
>>509434652 (OP)
The mass exodus of niggers into civilized society is a punishment I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy.
Anonymous ID: x14pwGG5
7/4/2025, 2:02:55 AM No.509444705
>>509434652 (OP)
Yanks didnt have niggers till the Great Migration
Anonymous ID: ZAHoGRkRUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:02:59 AM No.509444711
>>509434652 (OP)
they couldnt even if they wanted to. reconstruction failed and yankees can seethe.
Anonymous ID: PGlnU17VUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:05:04 AM No.509444851
>>509435696
confederate wasn't a party, ching chong wee wong
Anonymous ID: 0kRmpLhhUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:11:42 AM No.509445334
Screenshot 2025-07-03 at 8.11.17 PM
Screenshot 2025-07-03 at 8.11.17 PM
md5: 02cf06406eb5c5403ba3d72e1bdf44a4🔍
>>509444064
>all the blacks should have been deported back to Africa or given some island for their own
Anonymous ID: ezxoAULBUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:13:35 AM No.509445477
>>509434652 (OP)
confederates wanted slaves, right? what do the dems want?
Anonymous ID: m7ZlDHbFUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:14:15 AM No.509445536
>>509435782
Sherman was not aligned with the "republican radical" faction at all he had the Tywin Lannister philosophy to the South ie once they bent the knee they were to be helped to their feet.
Anonymous ID: wCFQLCjtUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:51:41 AM No.509448182
>>509435696
>>509434652 (OP)
The kikes have never been properly punished
Anonymous ID: DgShb9ruUnited States
7/4/2025, 2:54:05 AM No.509448356
>>509439193
Being on jewish reality TV is the perfect preparation for being in jewish politics.