consider the following: - /pol/ (#510168310) [Archived: 391 hours ago]

Anonymous ID: bP7rO0DdGermany
7/12/2025, 12:44:15 PM No.510168310
IMG_5779
IMG_5779
md5: 8d254c6e9313401063fb118c2f4817c3🔍
>In the world of Starship Troopers, corporal punishment, specifically flogging, is used as a form of public and communal punishment for both minors and adults who fail to uphold the rules. When a minor commits a transgression, their parents or guardians are also subjected to flogging alongside the child, emphasizing the shared responsibility for moral conduct and education.
Replies: >>510168373 >>510168473 >>510168934 >>510169787 >>510170326
Anonymous ID: HDxjDBDnUnited States
7/12/2025, 12:45:43 PM No.510168373
>>510168310 (OP)
corporal punishment should be reserved for adults, not children
Replies: >>510168527 >>510168830 >>510169282 >>510170092
Anonymous ID: zACmxy2SNetherlands
7/12/2025, 12:48:01 PM No.510168473
>>510168310 (OP)
It's hilarious how right wingers always fail to understand the point of Starship Troopers.
The film says democracy has fallen and was taken over by military veterans. Paul Verhoeven called them fascists and the entire film is a parody of Nazi propaganda.
https://www.theguardian.com/culture/2018/jan/22/how-we-made-starship-troopers-paul-verhoeven-nazis-leni-riefenstahl
https://www.digitalspy.com/movies/a823951/starship-troopers-paul-verhoeven-donald-trump-20-years-anniversary/

It truly scares me when people not only reject the meaning of art, but choose to twist it to their own meaning that is contrary to the artist.
Replies: >>510168595 >>510168680 >>510168767 >>510168877 >>510169145 >>510170081 >>510170668 >>510170683
Anonymous ID: bP7rO0DdGermany
7/12/2025, 12:49:33 PM No.510168527
>>510168373
It means that such punishment is so unusual as to be significant, to deter, to instruct. Back to these young criminals -- They probably were not spanked as babies; they certainly were not flogged for their crimes. The usual sentence was: for a first offence, a warning -- a scolding, often without trial. After several offenses a sentence of confinement but with sentence suspended and the youngster placed on probation. A boy might be arrested may times and convicted several times before he was punished -- and then it would be merely confinement, with others like him from whom he learned still more criminal habits. If he kept out of major trouble while confined, he could usually evade most of even that mild punishment, be given probation -- 'paroled' in the jargon of the times.
"This incredible sequence could go on for years while his crimes increased in frequency and viciousness, with no punishment whatever save rare dull-but-comfortable confinements. Then suddenly, usually by law on his eighteenth birthday, this so-called 'juvenile delinquent' becomes an adult criminal -- and sometimes wound up in only weeks or months in a death cell awaiting execution for murder."
Replies: >>510168712 >>510169037
Anonymous ID: nFIq3zmlUnited States
7/12/2025, 12:51:03 PM No.510168595
st
st
md5: c88725be9cf673d25a79f8a8e2e2908a🔍
>>510168473
Replies: >>510168967
Anonymous ID: 419iYD9gKyrgyzstan
7/12/2025, 12:53:14 PM No.510168680
>>510168473
>The film says democracy has fallen and was taken over by military veterans. Paul Verhoeven called them fascists and the entire film is a parody of Nazi propaganda.
You haven't read the book
Like many Leftist cucks, you think you understood the entire logic of a narrative by looking at a secondary source developed as a counter narrative by a Jewish director
Congratulations. Your sources are shit
Replies: >>510168914 >>510170668
Anonymous ID: nFIq3zmlUnited States
7/12/2025, 12:54:02 PM No.510168712
mobile infantry
mobile infantry
md5: 3ee2c9fe238198bc249d5bd5e7dbed4b🔍
>>510168527
i like this part a lot, when mr dubois is talking about the meaning of "cruel and unusual". punishment should be unusual. it should be so unusual because people aren't out violating the rights of others
Anonymous ID: bP7rO0DdGermany
7/12/2025, 12:55:13 PM No.510168767
>>510168473
Oh no humanity as a whole is working together as one big functioning society where people from every country and background can obtain the same rights but they are fighting killing Space Bugs! And the guy who didn't even read the books says this is literally what Hitler did!
AHHH IM GOING INSANE!
PLEASE DONT KILL THE SPACE BUGS! THIS IS FASCISM! REDDIT HELP ME!!
Replies: >>510168936
Anonymous ID: xZX59Yc7
7/12/2025, 12:56:38 PM No.510168830
>>510168373
Nah, if little shits get caught stealing and are too young to be prosecuted they have to go into the stocks for an hour while being pelted with rotten fruit and vegetables.
Anonymous ID: CoIu2i1RUnited States
7/12/2025, 12:57:35 PM No.510168877
>>510168473
Let's put an end to this trope once and for all. All this parody nonsense is an observational POV from niggerfaggots like you who have tried to mark it as one thing or another. But the movie failed as a parody, because it wasn't faithful to the book at all. It's like silver screen karma that it had the opposite effect.
Fuck off nigger, never post this meme again.
Replies: >>510170668
Anonymous ID: CoIu2i1RUnited States
7/12/2025, 12:58:42 PM No.510168914
>>510168680
hunanon knows
Anonymous ID: 4+0JgxReUnited Kingdom
7/12/2025, 12:59:06 PM No.510168934
175190062745356158
175190062745356158
md5: 657f8d0d1efb33db9d09c4015fc01b76🔍
>>510168310 (OP)
>corporal punishment
his surname was rico retard
Replies: >>510170979
Anonymous ID: nFIq3zmlUnited States
7/12/2025, 12:59:07 PM No.510168936
pseudoarachnid
pseudoarachnid
md5: 334340331409e4c0de5e3d3407a1e359🔍
>>510168767
friendly reminder that he blatantly compares chinese to insects
Anonymous ID: zWYXJ/ti
7/12/2025, 12:59:49 PM No.510168967
>>510168595
So this is what Verhoeven looked like? Huh...
Anonymous ID: HDxjDBDnUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:01:37 PM No.510169037
>>510168527
if your children need to be spanked, then you and they are racially inferior, which doesn't surprise me, given how unruly you germans are up there. thank god for the halbard.
Anonymous ID: TbcaBm2RUnited Kingdom
7/12/2025, 1:04:14 PM No.510169145
794268f4-2ec6-4c2a-b0e0-9b68cf7c9486_640x520
794268f4-2ec6-4c2a-b0e0-9b68cf7c9486_640x520
md5: e4407e8ed1c2240bcb5a89bc43765ccf🔍
>>510168473
We're just doing to the movie what the movie did to the book.
Replies: >>510169212 >>510170668
Anonymous ID: HDxjDBDnUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:06:06 PM No.510169212
>>510169145
it's just a children's movie
Anonymous ID: y1D2EfDGUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:07:44 PM No.510169282
>>510168373
Yeah I agree with this. And I'm pretty sure Hitler does too. I feel like its obvious to a white person to not blame a child.

All that said discipline should be applied. Just not like... 30 lashes or whatever. It should consist of education and extra work. The work reminds them they should listen to you. And its easier for them to learn.
Replies: >>510169415
Anonymous ID: HDxjDBDnUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:11:09 PM No.510169415
>>510169282
mazel tov brother
ChatTDG !!Z0MA/4gprbdID: blfpFTYG
7/12/2025, 1:20:07 PM No.510169787
>>510168310 (OP)

Positive reinforcement works better. More carrot than stick.
Anonymous ID: oZBnSRVOIreland
7/12/2025, 1:26:50 PM No.510170081
>>510168473
> It truly scares me when people not only reject the meaning of art, but choose to twist it to their own meaning that is contrary to the artist.
The message of the film is strongly opposed to the message of the original book.
Anonymous ID: r8yHykD9Canada
7/12/2025, 1:27:07 PM No.510170092
1751975234604628
1751975234604628
md5: b493d403eecd6eefcc389ac7cad7e280🔍
>>510168373
So
A stern talking to for stupid kids
Flogging for grown adults
You dumb? Kids don't understand much so a talking to won't do shit. Only thing a kid will learn from is a spanking.
Adults on the other hand have higher comprehension skills and this a stern talking to, at least to start, is more effective on adults.
Replies: >>510170394 >>510170637
Anonymous ID: JukJv3GCCanada
7/12/2025, 1:32:11 PM No.510170326
>>510168310 (OP)
I think public beating and humiliation is a lot more humane and fair than locking someone up in jail for months or years at a time. The only people that should be locked up should be people who are too dangerous to leave on the streets, violent criminals, everyone else should get a few dozen lashes at worst and set free.
Anonymous ID: HDxjDBDnUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:33:30 PM No.510170394
>>510170092
that's because your children are stupid niggers
Anonymous ID: YibjdfzNUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:38:37 PM No.510170637
>>510170092
>having retarded children
skill issue
Anonymous ID: jowE6hTwUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:39:10 PM No.510170668
>>510169145
>>510168473
>>510168680
>>510168877
I was told in school that what's truly important is how the reader interprets the work. there were entire classes dedicated to looking at things through this lens or that lens. now I'm being told what the author intended is what is truly important. how strange.
Anonymous ID: IDan7rkrUnited States
7/12/2025, 1:39:32 PM No.510170683
>>510168473
LoL, read the book faggot.
Anonymous ID: 2ZaWI9XXMexico
7/12/2025, 1:45:47 PM No.510170979
1670146503496230
1670146503496230
md5: 20aa33854cc9378402077079105125aa🔍
>>510168934