Is Private Wealth Illegitimate? - /pol/ (#510647105) [Archived: 299 hours ago]

Anonymous ID: oNOvkNh/United States
7/17/2025, 8:04:33 PM No.510647105
silver
silver
md5: 1acd54e598a7ff210d8f2e18256c8101๐Ÿ”
https://substack.com/home/post/p-168534108

So, are the theories that rationalize private wealth kind of bullshit actually?
In Anglo-Saxon society, private property was defended by your community, but so were the commons. There's a relationships between personal property and the commons, and the defense of one is related to the defense of the other.

Is unlimited, no questions asked, accumulated private wealth a scam? Libertarians are wrong that money emerges naturally from a state-less free market. The state always precedes the development of money wealth.

Does America need to stop protecting the economic power of the wealthy with our national debt and military? Should we let them crash out?
Maybe wealth should be stored in communities, and communities should be the bankers, where there's still a free market and private property, but no capitalist global trade mega-wealthy bullshit.
Replies: >>510648220
Anonymous ID: qz+lueIUUnited States
7/17/2025, 8:06:53 PM No.510647258
legitimacy is illegitimate (so private wealth lacking legitimacy [which it does not in either case] is not legitimate)
Replies: >>510647321
Anonymous ID: oNOvkNh/United States
7/17/2025, 8:07:45 PM No.510647321
>>510647258
Daytime retards roll call!
Anonymous ID: RPoynGC+Estonia
7/17/2025, 8:08:07 PM No.510647347
image (1)
image (1)
md5: e50c134d34a26cc724cea4d59749f7aa๐Ÿ”
Yes goy. You'll be renting everything. And you'll get the exact same slop as everyone else. Then we'll all be happy.
Replies: >>510649089
Anonymous ID: KJzDSxJAUnited States
7/17/2025, 8:19:37 PM No.510648220
IMG_4649
IMG_4649
md5: 69f95a8840d0a61b7682f0cca9465f59๐Ÿ”
>>510647105 (OP)
Youโ€™re not wrong, imo itโ€™s better to break down the idea of what private property is because there are two forms that people often put together.
>private property
This is like a bussiness, factory, apartment building etc etc
>personal property
House, car, TV, clothing, boat etc etc

Private property, you are correct 100%. Personal property should never be messed with though.
Replies: >>510648430 >>510649184
Anonymous ID: RPoynGC+Estonia
7/17/2025, 8:22:11 PM No.510648430
image
image
md5: 285c82e24bd56e500b329dc6e6620c60๐Ÿ”
>>510648220
Jimmy Dore show is great since cuckvid. When he himself is on. I don't trust all the jews there.
Anonymous ID: oNOvkNh/United States
7/17/2025, 8:30:56 PM No.510649089
>>510647347
Renting everything from private property owners.
Anonymous ID: oNOvkNh/United States
7/17/2025, 8:32:37 PM No.510649184
>>510648220
The commons is managed by local communities where people mostly know each other.
Private property shouldn't scale much beyond this level of politics.

I don't really go for the communist bullshit definition of personal vs. private property.
Under that definition, anything that's personal property can be deemed "public".
What I'm talking about has no "public" property, just commons.

Wealth that requires more than you and your gun to protect becomes part of the commons, because it requires the community to protect it.