which is more harmful?

If your primary concern is the health of your investments, the former. For literally anyone else, the latter

>which is more harmful?
overpopulation

The Black Death killed 50% but things bounced back quickly.
Europe will never recover from replacement.

>>511070514
not a real thing.

>>511070250 (OP)
Harmful to who? No change is free of trade-off.

>>511070589
Yup and it mostly ended the feudal system because there were more jobs needing to get done than people to do them, wages went up.

>>511070250 (OP)
ethnic replacement, no question about it. it kills any incentive to fix population

>>511070514
Half the world's population are in three countries: China, India, and Africa.

>>511070250 (OP)
Right
There' has been thousands of years of population growth and depopulation through famine and wars and the countries managed to persist through history. But getting demographically replaced by niggers and jeets? You are basically committing suicide

>>511072538
And those three (two countries and a continent) are 30% of Earth's land area

>>511070250 (OP)

Depopulation IS ultimately ethnic replacement. Millenials and zoomers complaining about the later are just not looking on long enough timelines because they're only concerned about what happens during their lifetimes

>>511070514
Ahahahahaha that's the last flag on the planet that should've written this comment. How's the 4B movement working out for Shit Korea?

>>511070250 (OP)
Ethnic replacement is worse.
There have been mass death events throughout history. Plagues, famines, natural disasters, genocides, etc. People rebounded from them, and here we are.
Really, your question is "depopulation or depopulation + replacement". The depopulation is happening, but people can't rebound if there's no room because it's been populated by outsiders, or if they've been mixed to the point of erasure.

>>511070250 (OP)
Send all the Jews to Jewpiter
Send all the shines to the Sun
Send all the Slavs to Uranus

>>511072741
Russia is almost twice as large as China but its population is less than half of China's.

Depopulation means your country will be ruled by other nations which means there will probably be lots of immigration anyway

There is not winning

>>511073071
>People rebounded from them
Society was never feminist when they rebounded.
Ukraine will rebound from the war right? What if I tell you Ukraine's pre-war fertility was 1.2? They needed a miracle to rebound from that now when the war is over they'll """"rebound""""" to 1.4 for a few years since people postponed having kids.
Once that is done with they'll go back to 1.2 lmao and that's all she wrote

In case you are unfamiliar 1.2 fertility is extinction level, worse than Black Plague Europe tier fertility lmao
And then there's SK with 0.8 zozzle, feminism is worse than the Black Plague

>>511070250 (OP)
I have a plan, lets collectively commit suicide, like the georgia guidestones said to do and lets give the world to the jews.
We release virusses which target racial markers of the red man, the black man, the white man and the yellow man but we spare the jews. Then we all collectively eat bacon and coof ourselfs to death on public places

Tikkun Olam

>>511073329
post a picture of your hand so i can confirm that you're a jeet

>>511073217
>Russia
Because 80% of the land is either frozen or mountainous

>>511070250 (OP)
There is no such thing as the depopulation option, all countries that have pyramid scheme pension systems will collapse, that is almost all countries on Earth.

Since women's freeeedoombs are untouchable and women are all princesses you will be forced to take immigrants?
Yes women will no longer be safe, yes women will get raped en masse and you know what? I DON'T GIVE FUCK :)

>>511070250 (OP)
depopulation, real talk
in any "sustainability" gimmick campaign, depopulation is the politically incorrect solution.
>every single problem address on higher population, higher demand, but limited resources
>all solutions are: renewables & recycling, resource optimization,
>but none talks of lowering demands: depopulation
since this is /pol/, the fulcrum question is "of what race"? further inquire on ethnic extermination.
no one on /pol/ will disagree if Georgia Guidestone specify that 500 million population is exclusively White.
>>511073571
East Asia is overpopulated, even commie chinks figured out 700 million is ideal (but gotta churn out more for cheap labor without any rights to win global economy war. China's population number isn't the problem, it's their gender ratio that is fucked up).
South Korea? 50 million at one small peninsula, it's overcrowded. 20 million and it'll enjoy even better quality of life
Depopulation of indian subcontinent via mortality however is a must!

>>511070250 (OP)
Both are problems that distract us from our own ethnic decadence.

>>511073605
>lets collectively commit suicide
Europe is already doing that ahahahaha
It's just gonna take 2-3 generations

>>511073863
>China's population number isn't the problem, it's their gender ratio that is fucked up
Threadly reminder there are 50 million homosexuals in China simply because there are not enough women

>>511073863
Pyramid scheme pension system.
You can't go from 50 mil to 20 mil without collapsing the pyramid scheme.
Young workers will be taxed 70% on their income to pay for boomers pensions LMAO

>>511074004
Takes too long, i want it now

>>511073413
There will always be a subset of the population that is above replacement, or becomes above replacement as things change, and they will inherit the earth.

The more you tax the private sector the more people leave forcing you to tax the private sector harder making more people leave and so on and so forth until you admit you can no longer pay pensions.
South Korea will take immigrants I'm sure of it. And many of them, oh boy will they take a lot.

>>511073730
And half of China is mostly desert

>>511074238
>or becomes above replacement as things change
What things? Feminism is literally the nr. 1 factor anything else while other factors are barely even relevant.
What makes you think feminism will ever change? Maybe it will change for the worse every year it gets crazier and crazier with no evidence of ever stopping.
So all that's left are patriarchal religious nutjobs, they are the only people who have on average 2+ kids, they are few and far between their groups only work at a small scale when it gets too big you can no longer control women.

>>511074370
What happens when Xi moves all the 300 million chinamen farmers to the east?

>>511070250 (OP)
Depopulation is fine. There is no issue whatsoever with depopulation, it just means letting geezers die off in poverty (those who didn't save for retirement) rather than receiving endless massive redistributions of tax revenue from the youth.
The vast majority of government debt is arising from paying off geezers who didn't pay enough into the system throughout their working lives (or else govt debt would not exist at all, period). There is no moral failing in letting geezers die off in poverty en masse.
Without the geezer burden on public finances, the domestic youth of today would prosper.
NO BROWNS NEEDED

>>511074047
All women are functionally homosexual since they prioritize a sterile sex life and make it their entire civic identity. That's why jews put out these blue haired troon freaks to be low hanging fruit for chuds to focus on even though they're minuscule compared to women.

>>511074841
New chinese restaurants, one in every city block and village. Online gambling everywhere. Every condominium unit will have 10 - 15 chinese tenants. Real estate prices will sky rocket. All these actually happened. And then Xi suddenly called all of them back to China. Really fucked up the real estate market.

>>511075060
>Oh wait geezers and women are the majority of voters so my retarded asinine "solution" is literally the least likely to be implemented
Kys cuck. Women owe men sex and babies. Depopulation is not an option and you will face the wall

>>511075453
>which is more harmful
Retard desert brownoid has comically poor reading comprehension, your inbred is showing.

>>511070250 (OP)
A healthy population should be expected to grow and shrink like anything in nature. So what there's less people... That's great. It means when the old generation dies there's abundance for the young generation, and they get to breed like crazy and fill up all the empty bedrooms.

>>511074004
>>511074207
Short sighted. It shrinks now and grows later. Your nigger brains can only imagine three generations but not six.

>>511070250 (OP)
i would rather live in an all white near ghost town than by any niggers.

>>511070250 (OP)
Replacement. Depopulation creates a vacuum that will be filled by your own people. Replacement pre-empts that vacuum and fills an existing population with foreigners, and therefore denies the original population the ability to expand.

>>511070250 (OP)
ethnic replacement
the immigrants are just enabling this system that undermines births to continue working. it manages the symptoms but not the cause
statistically immigrants also stop having children after the second gen too. because this shit hyper materialistic capitalist hell is anti life

>>511073064
You're right. I read your replies and you understand how destructive can an ideology be.

Politicians of SK love the "Divide and conquer" tactic so much that they've been using it for decades since the cold war. Rural vs Urban, Boomers vs Gen X vs Millenials/GenZ, now Male vs Female, huh?

And overpopulation is a problem. 50 millions in a tiny piece of land. Insane competition, competition, competition until you finally die. Suicide rate explains it as well.

Also, I hope you not to consume any brainrot junk media made in SK, it slowly changes how you think and behave.

>>511076479
Were all gonna make it
World peace and love
https://youtu.be/DyLAqOEyteA

>>511076232
Inbred is better than no bred, HAHAHAHAH fuckin coper faggot
"P-please don't c-come here brown ppl..
Let us die out in peace no invasion"
Doesn't work like that bitch

>>511070250 (OP)
What a retarded question. What do you think, retard?

>>511070250 (OP)
you have both happening at the same time

>>511070250 (OP)
Anything that involves Indians is bad news.

>>511077929
False, depop PRECEDES AND JUSTIFIES mass migration for labor, every single time, finally happening in NE Asia precisely because cucks like the ones here argued that depop wasn't a problem.

Just fuckin lol that they wanna come around now pretending the migrants fell from the sky "hurr Durr how could the Jews do this to us??"

>>511074712
>What things?
If the education system collapsed. If an antifeminist movement rises. If a new wave of feminists refuse to be defined by corporate careers. etc.
>What makes you think feminism will ever change?
I'm not confident feminism will change, but it's an unsustainable ideology
>So all that's left are patriarchal religious nutjobs, they are the only people who have on average 2+ kids, they are few and far between their groups only work at a small scale when it gets too big you can no longer control women.
Then the future will be a world of patriarchal religious nutjobs living in small scale societies. Just like virtually all of human history.