Why is it a hot take that certain words should be responded to with violence?

If a person is insulted or otherwise derided with great injury to their honor, they should be in the right to unholster their firearm (they carry since they're exemplary citizens) and kill the rude person.

Anyone who disagrees with this utopian scenario either insults or is actively planning to insult someone else.

You don't get to just shoot someone because they called you a faggot. That's not how it works.

>>81945618
Genuinely why did you post this? I know that isn't how it works, everyone reading knows this isn't how it works. You're not contributing anything to this discussion.

Morality has nothing to do with laws. I'm arguing that since it is morally right to do what I described, it should be codified into law. You dodged the question and debate entirely and just said "yeah but it's not legal tho". I know it's not legal.

>>81945672
It isn't remotely proportionate or morally justified to shoot someone over words alone. Retard.

>>81945762
Well it really depends on what's being said or done. There are levels to it. If they're trying to emasculate you or cuck you or something, it CAN ruin your life. Obviously that's on a different level from them just calling you a fuckface because you're having a disagreement or something.

>>81945883
Then you throw hands and knock his ass out. Don't shoot an unarmed person. That's pussy shit.

>>81945929
Why would you use an inefficient method that could potentially fail?

Remember, in this scenario the other person has tried to emasculate you or cuck you. Why wouldn't you draw?

>>81945591 (OP)
honor is all in your head

>>81945591 (OP)
I agree, people should be ready to stand by their words under the pain of death.
>you inc-ACK
>you nig-ACK
and it doesnt matter who women(especially) can get it too

>>81945929
>if some 6'4" 300 pound guy starts humiliating and emasculating you, just beat him up.

>>81946023
i think i could unironically beat a 6'4 300 pound dude but id rather shoot or stab him out of pure malice thoughbeit

>>81945969
You are too pussyfooted to fight evenly maybe there is a reason you are being ridiculed. Ofcourse you could choose to murder the guy but you cant really masturbate to anime in prison, bitchboy.

>>81946097
>If you happen to be born into a body that's smaller than another man's, you deserve to have your life ruined via bullying and emasculation.
Or maybe if you really act like this, you deserve to get shot.

>>81946142
Understand a natural pecking order exists and don't try to be a bigshot when you can be easily dominated.

>>81946048
You're either a gorilla-human hybrid straight out of a Russian laboratory or the most delusional man alive.
>>81946097
There is no such thing as an even fight. Even if the rude cunt were the same size and weight class as me for some unfathomable reason such as fate itself tailoring this hypothetical to be as favorable for you as possible... guess what? It wouldn't be an even fight. Maybe the guy went to his martial arts classes diligently and I missed mine because of a major event in my life. There you go, that's an uneven fight.

Why would I care about an even fight? If I had a weapon I would use it to gain the edge.

>>81946213
Why does my thread attract retards holy shit. Is asking you *not* to put down other people really that big an ask?

>>81946234
Most people are cowards when it comes to combat, bullies especially. If you make it clear that you're not easy to dominate via a hard strike to the nose, jaw, etc. He will go down like a sack of shit. The glory of this victory would redeem the cucking and secure your place in Elysium.

>>81946213
It would be nice if that's how it worked, but there are people out there who go out of their way to humiliate others completely unprovoked.

>>81946556
There are a small number of remarkably insecure individuals who do this, sounds cliche but it's best to just ignore them. If someone is doing this unprovoked then there is obviously something wrong with them.

>>81946234
>You're either a gorilla-human hybrid straight out of a Russian laboratory
no i've just been fighting all my life basically not just street fights or defending my self from bullies which has happened but also actually training.
im also not to far from that height and weight.
also most people of that height and weight are extremely unfit and and have slow reactions in a fight.
i've only fought one person close to that height and weight that was actually a decent fighter.

>>81945672
>You dodged the question and debate entirely and just said "yeah but it's not legal tho". I know it's not legal.
NTA but it's not morally right to do so either.
>>81945883
Also no.
>someone calls you a faggot
rude but okay
>oh wow someone called anon a faggot and he didn't chimp out, I'm not gonna hire him lmao I don't want any cucks working here
This is the one in the wrong, not the random guy who called him a faggot.
It's not right to punish something -that will lead to other things-, just punish those other things.

The other major problem with your insanity is that it's entirely open to speculation.
Picture your mentally ill society 5 generations into the future:
>hey man what's up
>the fuck you'd just say to me? You coming onto me homo lala boy?
>what?
>you said hello to me. why the fuck would you start a conversation with me if you weren't wanting a piece of my ass?
>...what?
>*BLAM BLAM BLAM*
>fucking faggots (morally justified because he thought he was being emasculated)

>>81945591 (OP)
Just dont cry when you escalate from non actionable threats to violence and get got yourself

>>81945591 (OP)
Because it's cringe and we should be more civilized than that. If someone calls you a faggot retard which you are killing them is the most chimp out nigger thing you could do. The only time I would see it acceptable to respond to words with violence is if it's verbal threats directed at you. When it comes to other things like stealing without use of violence though for example I do think you should be able to just kill the person to strop them from stealing your shit.

>>81947127
I'm talking more about something like, you go to a bar, and then some random thug goes over to you and starts insulting you and shit, or trying to get the girl you're with to ditch you if you happen to be with a girl. That type of situation can ruin your life. It can cause guys to not want to be around you because they view you as weak and embarrassing, and it can turn you into an incel because girls stop finding you attractive. And if you try to fight him and get beat up, that just makes things even worse for you. Anyways, killing someone over something like that isn't really that morally bad. It hardly even counts as killing a human, it's more like killing an aggressive ape creature.

>>81946234
>Why would I care about an even fight?
Well, you're blabbing about "muh honor", so people would expect you to fight with honor.
People used to duel to restore/preserve their honor, you know. But that didn't involve suddenly pulling a gun on an unarmed opponent.

>yeah bro simply reduce your chances of success in a fight to the death, it's just honor bro
Maybe don't reduce your chances of being alive by insulting people.

wait wtf my post bumped the thread back to page 1 and I'm the OP
what is this cursed board?

>honor is important enough that you should kill for it
>but not important enough to abide by a code of honor yourself
Uh-huh. You don't even know what honor is, despite using that word in the OP yourself. You're just getting high off of this cheap power fantasy where you gun down people who slighted you, because you have neither the wits nor physical prowess to defend that so-called honor of yours otherwise (but don't worry, you don't have any to begin with).
And yeah, I also thought OP cannot bump his own thread, what is up with that? Was that changed at some point?