Anonymous
10/30/2025, 9:02:22 AM
No.24840856
>>24840393
Can't remmember if that sentence was uttered by a character or the narrator. If it was by a character, I don't see anything wrong about characters speaking incorrectly. Nobody does speak correctly at all times. But yeah, some of grrm's critics ate just nitpickers. Many crticisms are perfectly valid, that being said.
>>24840554
Yeah, LOTR is about a world that's about to end and the coming world lacks the wonder and the beauty. Could be Tolkien lamenting the old world that ended after WWI. Anyway, I agree that nobody captured the sadness of that sentiment as beautifully as Tolkien.
Can't remmember if that sentence was uttered by a character or the narrator. If it was by a character, I don't see anything wrong about characters speaking incorrectly. Nobody does speak correctly at all times. But yeah, some of grrm's critics ate just nitpickers. Many crticisms are perfectly valid, that being said.
>>24840554
Yeah, LOTR is about a world that's about to end and the coming world lacks the wonder and the beauty. Could be Tolkien lamenting the old world that ended after WWI. Anyway, I agree that nobody captured the sadness of that sentiment as beautifully as Tolkien.