Anonymous
10/30/2025, 11:56:23 PM
No.24842529
>>24842510
But that's not what the words say. It cannot be the way you say because the words contradict that entirely. You couldn't possibly know otherwise, which is why I said you made it up. The poster above asked if McCarthy can write an uplifting story, and I answered that he did, but your argument is that the words do not mean what they are, that's unintelligible. Even more so, your argument is that McCarthy can't write an uplifting story because he writes mostly tragedies, except in this case, where you say it's not uplifting because the others aren't uplifting, it's circular.
But that's not what the words say. It cannot be the way you say because the words contradict that entirely. You couldn't possibly know otherwise, which is why I said you made it up. The poster above asked if McCarthy can write an uplifting story, and I answered that he did, but your argument is that the words do not mean what they are, that's unintelligible. Even more so, your argument is that McCarthy can't write an uplifting story because he writes mostly tragedies, except in this case, where you say it's not uplifting because the others aren't uplifting, it's circular.