Anonymous
10/10/2025, 8:46:19 PM
No.4473938
>>4473931
Thank you, I accept your criticisms.
As I have already said, I find this type of photography very hard.
Trying to convey this entire magnificent scene full of things I find beautiful for many different reasons with just one image.
I still think that I managed to do it in this one, without it devolving into a disjointed clusterfuck, and I did explain why I think they all work together creating a harmonic-enough visual composition.
Maybe it does come to personal preferences.
Judging by your preference for OP's photo, you like negative space, black shadows, moody skies, flat colors.
But to me, it just doesn't offer much to look at, and without a strong subject to capture my attention I immediately start analyzing it technically and boom, it falls apart.
I kinda find this >>4473547 series (together as a whole, not individual photos by themselves) more compelling, especially when viewed as thumbnails without trying to pay attention to details.
Maybe next time I'm in the mood for some difficult scene I'll try to make it a series of simpler compositions instead.
Anyway, OP said he just wanted to capture the boat, so none of this "scene-as-a-whole" gibberish applies really.
>>4473933
Thanks you for positivity, I just hope this thread doesn't degrade any further.
Maybe OP can post some more images of his for people to talk about.
This might quell the upcoming shitstorm.
Thank you, I accept your criticisms.
As I have already said, I find this type of photography very hard.
Trying to convey this entire magnificent scene full of things I find beautiful for many different reasons with just one image.
I still think that I managed to do it in this one, without it devolving into a disjointed clusterfuck, and I did explain why I think they all work together creating a harmonic-enough visual composition.
Maybe it does come to personal preferences.
Judging by your preference for OP's photo, you like negative space, black shadows, moody skies, flat colors.
But to me, it just doesn't offer much to look at, and without a strong subject to capture my attention I immediately start analyzing it technically and boom, it falls apart.
I kinda find this >>4473547 series (together as a whole, not individual photos by themselves) more compelling, especially when viewed as thumbnails without trying to pay attention to details.
Maybe next time I'm in the mood for some difficult scene I'll try to make it a series of simpler compositions instead.
Anyway, OP said he just wanted to capture the boat, so none of this "scene-as-a-whole" gibberish applies really.
>>4473933
Thanks you for positivity, I just hope this thread doesn't degrade any further.
Maybe OP can post some more images of his for people to talk about.
This might quell the upcoming shitstorm.