Anonymous
10/9/2025, 4:38:04 PM
No.96715079
>>96713573
You're such a fucking retard. You can't seem to grasp the objective fact the game just lifts historical cultures and translates them into the game in direct allegory, rendering all your arguments about "well actually in the lore" moot. The lore barely makes any sense half the time, if we're being realistic none of our modern day cultures would exist at all on these foreign planets and everything would be more like dune. But they threw out realism in favor of having space vikings because they wanted vikings in space.
>Because his opinion is dumb
No it's nuanced and correct
>Name one culture that didn't change over a long period of time.
Not what you said, you said mixing was common, implying the mixing we see today is common. It isn't.
>And also routine
But difficult and dangerous and limited. You aren't getting mass movements of people across star systems. Cultures are mostly self contained to their planets and systems.
>So what?. Even an isolated culture will change and evolve.
Yeah your point is retarded. That's why they threw away realism to make an allegory to modern day cultures. Ultramarines are space romans. 40k is actually really bad at conveying deep time. This just reinforces my argument of these factions being unrealistic parallels to modern day cultures. You can't have your cake and eat it too when it comes to realism.
>3 of those controlled, or still control territories so vast with so many ethnic and racial groups that your own argument falls apart under its own stupidity.
You're deliberately ignoring what I'm saying. And space wolves lore had them be slightly darker than normal, not full on black anywhere. On a planet deliberately design to ape Scandinavian myth.
>Sticking a few visual elements onto something doesn't make it a coherent allegory for anything.
This is just pure cope. You can't twist yourself into knots trying to act like these aren't allegories. It's more than just visual dude.
You're such a fucking retard. You can't seem to grasp the objective fact the game just lifts historical cultures and translates them into the game in direct allegory, rendering all your arguments about "well actually in the lore" moot. The lore barely makes any sense half the time, if we're being realistic none of our modern day cultures would exist at all on these foreign planets and everything would be more like dune. But they threw out realism in favor of having space vikings because they wanted vikings in space.
>Because his opinion is dumb
No it's nuanced and correct
>Name one culture that didn't change over a long period of time.
Not what you said, you said mixing was common, implying the mixing we see today is common. It isn't.
>And also routine
But difficult and dangerous and limited. You aren't getting mass movements of people across star systems. Cultures are mostly self contained to their planets and systems.
>So what?. Even an isolated culture will change and evolve.
Yeah your point is retarded. That's why they threw away realism to make an allegory to modern day cultures. Ultramarines are space romans. 40k is actually really bad at conveying deep time. This just reinforces my argument of these factions being unrealistic parallels to modern day cultures. You can't have your cake and eat it too when it comes to realism.
>3 of those controlled, or still control territories so vast with so many ethnic and racial groups that your own argument falls apart under its own stupidity.
You're deliberately ignoring what I'm saying. And space wolves lore had them be slightly darker than normal, not full on black anywhere. On a planet deliberately design to ape Scandinavian myth.
>Sticking a few visual elements onto something doesn't make it a coherent allegory for anything.
This is just pure cope. You can't twist yourself into knots trying to act like these aren't allegories. It's more than just visual dude.