>>541760931
>She is just butch
Not even, she's just a very gallant tomboy. Who tends to get easily flustered when she's out of her depth.
>Most obvious we have the fact she gets called ''Prince'' and feels comfortable being portrayed in a masculine manner
She's playing the role for Little Mermaid, who is a classic fairy tale princess-type.
>I personally think this is due to her original nightmare form being male
Genderless at worst.
>her full nightmare form resides in the Underground Cavern and is believed to be based on the pied piper (a MALE character)
So is Hameln, who is unarguably female. In fact, the whole Pied Piper thing is likely a relic from the original game when the Underground Nightmare wasn't tied to Otsuu.
>In the locked up in love visual novel Jack fails to realize Otsuu is a woman and calls her ''brother'
Jack has the density of a black hole.
>I ask you this; Does it not make sense that a male nightmare would wish to be a Blood Maiden
Her wish wasn't that specific, she just wished to be with Little Mermaid. The Witchcraft made her into a tomboyish blood maiden so she could fulfill a role as Little Mermaid's "prince". Blood Youths already exist as male equivalents to Blood Maidens, so if that were the case, "he" should be reborn as a Blood Youth. But she became a Blood Maiden instead. If anything, that just implies she was always a girl.
Have I mentioned how much I hate how troons latch onto tomboyish characters like Otsuu to propagate their death cult? "Hurr durr she acts like a fairy tale prince so she must have a stinking axe wound just like me xisters". Dial 8 you faggot and leave the cute crane princewife out of your gay cult.