I mean Super Mario Bros. beats the ever loving shit out of all of the other ones no contest. That's not to say that these other games aren't any good, I personally have always been really fond of Popeye, but the majority of these games are single screen, black background games that usually have stiff movement and are just about getting a high score. Then Mario comes along and has colorful and diverse graphics, complex controls with physics that still feel great, smooth scrolling, tons of levels and secrets, etc. It really can't be overstated what a revolutionary game it was.