>>212980956
I think in terms of old skool charisma it seems like he's visibly putting in too much effort, as opposed to the effortless charm Chris Pratt has.

>>212980995
Similar here, he comes off a bit too practiced in a smug kinda way. Not enough of that 'everyman' type charm.

What I'm talking about is like a perfect triple point of seeminly natural easy-going nature, confidence, and humbleness, that kind of thing. Not too much of this, or too little of that.

For example, you might think of someone like Ryan Reynolds, but he's too me-me-me attention-seeking, fast-talking, etc. to really have that pure and broad appeal where they have the maximum number of people like them while having the minimum number of people hate them. Reynolds goes overboard to the point of starting to generate hate, (and I'm speaking before recent events at the height of his popularity).

So don't necessarily have to be A-listers or pretty-boy leading men to have it.

Scott Grimes does a better job of being a little on that loud side but still being extremely close to the optimum point. So much so it's noticeable against any remaining cast:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/nWJHzDnD_Bc