just marathoned silent hill 2 and i think james never had sex with mary he was a truecel through and through

when you go up against the final boss you get all those flashbacks of mary yelling at james blaming him for her illness yada yada who the hell would tap that bitch?

then theres the letter from laura where she says that james is a quiet curly haired white boy who seems like a strong silent type like gary cooper but deep down hes a polite sensitive guy

james never loved mary he was just stuck in some fantasy version of maria in that insane noggin of his if you were not filtered by apartments youd know that