...You decide to:

Speech:
>Introduce yourself in kind, as Lucy "?" (Write-In a decent Scots-Irish or otherwise Southern Surname)
>"Captain will do just fine."
>Say Nothing
>Write-In

Action:
>Walk down to meet him on equal footing
>Keep the highground
>Aim your laser at him
>Write-In

Direction:
>Whisper to Lorraine to take aim at him or his crew
>Tell the others to stay back, he's only seen Lorraine
>Tell the others to come out for the meeting
>Write-In

(Choose one of each category for how the "parlay" starts)