Search Results
ID: sV0sHwf6/pol/509354579#509379737
7/3/2025, 9:51:28 AM
>>509379538
>Many early modern scholars accepted the authenticity of the work, including Franciscus Quaresmius, Balthasar de Monconys, and Kara Mustafa Pasha.[7][8] The modern Muslim scholar John Andrew Morrow also believes in the authenticity of the document, pointing out that the document is replicated verbatim across numerous Islamic sources, including more than a thousand years of Caliphs and Sultans.[9][10][11] However, since the 19th century several aspects of the Ashtiname, notably the list of witnesses, have been questioned by some scholars,[12] with several noting the lack of any reference to such documents in classical Islamic texts.[13] There are similarities to other documents granted to other religious communities in the Near East. One example is Muhammad's alleged letter to the Christians of Najran, which first came to light in 878 in a monastery in Iraq and whose text is preserved in the Chronicle of Seert.[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashtiname_of_Muhammad
You mean this lord of war?
>Many early modern scholars accepted the authenticity of the work, including Franciscus Quaresmius, Balthasar de Monconys, and Kara Mustafa Pasha.[7][8] The modern Muslim scholar John Andrew Morrow also believes in the authenticity of the document, pointing out that the document is replicated verbatim across numerous Islamic sources, including more than a thousand years of Caliphs and Sultans.[9][10][11] However, since the 19th century several aspects of the Ashtiname, notably the list of witnesses, have been questioned by some scholars,[12] with several noting the lack of any reference to such documents in classical Islamic texts.[13] There are similarities to other documents granted to other religious communities in the Near East. One example is Muhammad's alleged letter to the Christians of Najran, which first came to light in 878 in a monastery in Iraq and whose text is preserved in the Chronicle of Seert.[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashtiname_of_Muhammad
You mean this lord of war?
Page 1