>>533648632
>>533558435
I'm going to rate each of these designs using the most reliable and relatable system there is - my subjective opinion.

Gladius - thousand_chimer's version is too civilised. For an anthropomorphic cerberus monster give me something that is wild, with fur and torn clothes. Uniform and hat should belong to someone like Heolstor. The boss' distinct elements represented by pauldrons, chain, tie and bracelets seem shoehorned and create a visual clutter. Overall 5/10.
Our resident aislopper gets more points for the delinquent archetype, but again, too civilised. 7/10

Adel - the giant maw being the skirt feels, once again, shoehorned. Also not a fan of a crown on gothic lolita. 5/10
Aidel is pretty much perfect. The shark teeth, tongue, hoodie with a mob eye create a strong aura of a sloppy, lazy neet girl. Nailed the idea, execution and similarity to the boss. Would be even better if she had a tail. 10/10

Gnoster - both solid depictions of a delicate and airy caster, nothing to criticise. The finished thousand_chimer version will surely get full marks. 9/10
AI loses point for only 1 pair of wings and their boring shape/colors. 9/10 (Animus is 10/10 tho)

Faurtis - the archetype of a burly musclebrain wearing armor... IS SO DULL! I wouldn't know how to tackle it in interesting way either. Maybe full cicada armor should get some points, but I genuinely don't care. Both 2/10.

Maris - same case as Gnoster. The designs are on point and make my pp happy. Finished thousand_chimer version gets 10/10. AI gets 9.5/10 for being a jellyfish instead of a man o'war.

Libra - why is the goat demon a Chinese martial artist? I feel like it's just for the sake of it, but she isn't a visual clutter like Gladius or Adel. I also like her crazed expression and tufts of fur. 8/10
Aibra is just goat legs, ears and horns slapped on a girl. Fantastic pear shape, though. 6/10

to be cont.