Search Results
5/11/2025, 9:33:37 PM
In the past when I was really into old bikes I rode countless hours on bikes with downtube or bar end friction shifters. These days my fleet is almost all modern, but I do still have one classic steel bike with a friction downtube shifter for the front mech.
Friction shifting performance (speed, smoothness) can be 10/10 perfect with good shifters, a modern chain, and a modern cassette with close ratios. But friction shifting always requires more rider input and forethought than indexing, usually requires taking a hand away from where it would otherwise be resting on the handlebar, and doesn't work as smoothly when jumps between gear ratios are larger.
So I have nothing against friction shifting, but at the same time, unless I'm deliberately building or restoring a classic bike there's no way I'm choosing friction shifters. I might make an exception for some Growtac Equal shifters if they were available to me, but I'd have to find the right project for them...
Friction shifting performance (speed, smoothness) can be 10/10 perfect with good shifters, a modern chain, and a modern cassette with close ratios. But friction shifting always requires more rider input and forethought than indexing, usually requires taking a hand away from where it would otherwise be resting on the handlebar, and doesn't work as smoothly when jumps between gear ratios are larger.
So I have nothing against friction shifting, but at the same time, unless I'm deliberately building or restoring a classic bike there's no way I'm choosing friction shifters. I might make an exception for some Growtac Equal shifters if they were available to me, but I'd have to find the right project for them...
Page 1