Search Results
8/7/2025, 3:53:44 PM
So the anon in another thread who was talking with me about Seikore had a good point- it's a better competition overall than Miss Magazine.
>>49824036
Oji-chan, you're drunk, go back to sleep!
I thought he was crazy at first, but if you remove the winners who went stratospheric (Aika and Hina), the success of Miss Maga has left a lot to be desired. Typically one or two of the girls from the top 6 have nice idol careers where they continue on in gravure as well, but there's never been an IV from a top 6 finisher, and most of them are totally gone from entertainment careers within 2 years. I challenge anyone to name a winner from Miss Magazine 2020 that isn't Hina, let alone the overall winner (who even did a trio shoot with Aika and Runa!). I don't even know her name offhand. Seikore girls meanwhile tend to embrace gravure or idol careers more openly, and while being a mid-tier popularity gravure idol isn't the best result, the fact that they have staying power is nice. It doesn't feel like a waste to follow them during the GP only to have them fuck off forever later.
Seikore also tends to have more attractive girls overall, not sure why that is but again if you remove the outliers you can see that Miss Maga tends to go for very plain girls that don't look like idols or even portrait models, yet their winners always have some exceptional quality the rest of the field doesn't. 2023 is kind of an exception I felt, not sure if it was intentional to make the pool younger and cuter or what, but I think the continued success of all '23 winners led us to the current GP where there's many high level girls among the top 16.
Seikore is also more geared towards actual gravure (one of the winner titles is literally Miss Gravure) so we get better stuff from the girls. 2022's Ishii Yuki has done 3 IVs already, which would never happen with Miss Maga, and you gotta figure some of the JKs will make some once they get older.
>>49824036
Oji-chan, you're drunk, go back to sleep!
I thought he was crazy at first, but if you remove the winners who went stratospheric (Aika and Hina), the success of Miss Maga has left a lot to be desired. Typically one or two of the girls from the top 6 have nice idol careers where they continue on in gravure as well, but there's never been an IV from a top 6 finisher, and most of them are totally gone from entertainment careers within 2 years. I challenge anyone to name a winner from Miss Magazine 2020 that isn't Hina, let alone the overall winner (who even did a trio shoot with Aika and Runa!). I don't even know her name offhand. Seikore girls meanwhile tend to embrace gravure or idol careers more openly, and while being a mid-tier popularity gravure idol isn't the best result, the fact that they have staying power is nice. It doesn't feel like a waste to follow them during the GP only to have them fuck off forever later.
Seikore also tends to have more attractive girls overall, not sure why that is but again if you remove the outliers you can see that Miss Maga tends to go for very plain girls that don't look like idols or even portrait models, yet their winners always have some exceptional quality the rest of the field doesn't. 2023 is kind of an exception I felt, not sure if it was intentional to make the pool younger and cuter or what, but I think the continued success of all '23 winners led us to the current GP where there's many high level girls among the top 16.
Seikore is also more geared towards actual gravure (one of the winner titles is literally Miss Gravure) so we get better stuff from the girls. 2022's Ishii Yuki has done 3 IVs already, which would never happen with Miss Maga, and you gotta figure some of the JKs will make some once they get older.
Page 1