Jewish: brown mustard
Goyish: yellow mustard

Jewish: dill pickles
Goyish: sweet pickles

Jewish: beef
Goyish: pork

Jewish: latkes
Goyish: hashbrowns

Jewish: Coney Island
Goyish: Disneyland

Jewish: observing a holy day
Goyish: celebrating a holiday

Jewish: hummus
Goyish: mayonnaise
Painfully goyish: ranch dressing
Goyish trying to be cool: sriracha

Jewish: Florida
Goyish: Texas

Jewish: hamburger
Goyish: cheeseburger

Jewish: blue
Goyish: red

Jewish: Cayman Islands
Goyish: Jamaica

Jewish: New York
Goyish: Buffalo

Any other examples?