Thats me
I thought long and hard over the years of whats in the category of "the best movies"
And there just does not seem to be a flaw with the pirates and I gave it #1 spot

>great acting all around, most praise Jack but everyone is so good, barbarosa steals every scene too
>dialogues that are witty and interesting and move story forward
>overall plot is well written and pacing is excelent
>soundtrack is legendary by now
>cinematography is great
>little attention to details you see through the movie
>no minorities or too much women or messaging