Has this ever been refuted?

Any good books that rebut this book, point by point?

After reading about dialectic I'm also wondering if it's a common thing for a book to be published and then later for another book by another author to be antithesis to the former. Do you have any examples of a series of books where each rebuts the preceding book? Have you read any such books? Thoughts on that? Were you persuaded by a book, and then persuaded by the rebuttal too, or what happened?