Search Results
6/28/2025, 6:19:20 AM
>>95968688
He is wrong about 2e. On many levels. His insistence on 2e being only about storytelling/railroading is completely wrong and is on the level of propaganda, not critique. He even attacks QoL changes just because he can't accept any reason why people should dare to play 2e.
2e is far from the best iteration of D&D, but it's actually surprisingly quite popular, especially among the OSR community. On the Dragonsfoot forums, it's actually more popular than OD&D and only 2nd to AD&D 1e.
But, at the end of it all, the exaggeration of how different 1e and 2e are has gotten kind of silly at this point.
He is wrong about 2e. On many levels. His insistence on 2e being only about storytelling/railroading is completely wrong and is on the level of propaganda, not critique. He even attacks QoL changes just because he can't accept any reason why people should dare to play 2e.
2e is far from the best iteration of D&D, but it's actually surprisingly quite popular, especially among the OSR community. On the Dragonsfoot forums, it's actually more popular than OD&D and only 2nd to AD&D 1e.
But, at the end of it all, the exaggeration of how different 1e and 2e are has gotten kind of silly at this point.
Page 1