>>96770302
>lurker here
You basically got it.
pro 2e: still has the mechanical AD&D legacy and thus could reasonably support the old playstyle, though worse in some aspects.
contra 2e: switch to new intended playstyle, adventures are mainly linear stories.
You could be partisan on both sides depending if you emphasize remaining substance or meta direction.
The resident troll (or trolls) works this corner to milk his daily dopamine micro dose of attention. All there is to it. Doesn't really matter aside from being noise that drowns out actual gaming content. A tale as old as the internet.
Personally I think 2e is a perfectly fine pile of salvage parts to use at leisure.