>>150828230
The only thing I remember about Wilkins was that he's part of why the tournaments nearly died. Temp used a picture of Wilkins strangling a janny as a thread OP and that's when the threads started getting pruned.

Carl's current campaign is almost entirely reliant on an unrelated more popular (but still unqualified) character doing all the heavy lifting for the story arc. I don't believe Carl is as forced as Gagne was, I think Carl gets genuine love, but I just don't see the momentum. He lost round 1 last year and he's about to take another early exit to Ronnie from Whomp! comics. At least Blacksad and Mansley have won things.

This might be controversial but I'd argue Carl = Marco because both of them are only noteworthy for getting into a tournament they shouldn't be in through deception. They're pretty insignificant besides that.

I don't remember anything about the Emperor of Mankind. I know Ramses does a lot of rp campaign, I don't know if he ever qualified.

So in my opinion
Mansley = Blacksad > Ramses > Carl = Marco > Wilkins >>> Gagne