>>151183667
Why is it liked?
>Some people felt X-Men were in the cold for many years because of the Inhuman push because Marvel execs downplayed the X-Men whilst not having the movie rights but here they were back in a major way.
>All your characters were back, your favourites were back, all your teams were back.
>House/Powers of X was okay, or interesting enough to get people invested.
>It was new and different enough, people like a lot of big status quo changing risks....
>... especially when it comes to vast new dynamics for the characters/teams.
>Plenty of artists, writers and creators that mainstream fans enjoy.

Why do people hate it?
>Immortality shit was weird, it felt conceptually like clones.
>X-Men behaved like a cult.
>Too many titles, crossovers, connections.
>Your favourite characters were spread across SO MANY BOOKS.
>Classic Hickman, initial concepts interesting but then shit the bed.
>Hickman was essentially kicked off the book because he had plans for where it was going to go but the other writers were eating well with good sales so revolted against his plans...
>.. this lead to the era going on for FAR TOO LONG.
>So much poor characterisation.
>So many well memed moments, the cuck diagram on the moon (Jean's bedroom had doors into Wolverine/Cyclops hut), the whole make more mutants (orgy island/sex/cuckoldry type shit), the Magneto dinner speech.