After hours of introspection and hard analysis I have resolved the perfect tier list.

After dozens of hours of analysis, this is the tier list.
>Freddy joins Alex, Burt, and Jon to form the Fishtank Mt. Rushmore.
>Rachel is solid C-tier for an entertaining yet one-dimensional week's performance where her presence was undeniable.
>Angelina had some personality but was largely forgettable aside from her relationship with Daniel.
>Ellie is arguably the worst fish of all time, despite being probably the most attractive.
>Jin can't be higher simply because of his brevity, but I think he could've broken into B-tier or even A-tier if Jet wasn't a sensitive faggot.
>Drench was especially hard to rank because I think she had potential and a certain charisma, but she just didn't do much time with her time in the tank. With a full season I think she would've been a lock for B-tier.
>Aryeh and Daniel are memorable characters, if unlikable. I debated putting Daniel lower because of his sulking. With a longer season he could've gone up or down. Aryeh would've probably ended up at C-tier either way unless he really got aggressive with Freddy.
>Seth wasn't on the tier list maker but I'd put him at D-tier. He seemed to be coming into his own though near the end and could've made C-tier with more time.
Overall a very mediocre cast hard-carried by Freddy and made worse by Jet. It sucks we won't see more of Freddy.