I am new to /pg/ and only played P3 Reload.
At first I was like 'Oh great another strange japanese game about teenagers' (I am way over 40). But later I got really into it. I love all the girls. I love Yuko Nishiwaki. I wish there were more of her in the game. She is so unbelievably cute.
The story is fine for a game aimed at teenagers but nothing special. Shed a tear or two though.
Overall I consider playing it a time well spent.

Was Persona 3 a good game?